Home            Past Issues            About IP            About IAP           Author Information            Subscription            Advertisement              Search  

   
correspondence

Indian Pediatr 2010;47: 982-983

Reply


M Ramprasad

Email: [email protected]
 


We express thanks for the special interest and the questions raised pertaining to our article. With a cross-sectional design, our study explored the relationship between putative cause and effect i.e., backpack weight and postural angles in conveniently selected population. The population was stratified, excluded for larger measurement variability and represented homo-genous postural stability for a complex functional task (functional reach) than simple loading task measured in our study set-up. This reduces the impact of anthropometric confounding factors such as subcutaneous fat and height and their influence on postural angles in present study. Moreover good precision obtained in measured postural angles dictates good reproducibility with a valid ImageTool for the measurements taken.

To put clearly, data only on backpack weight and postural angles would not allow the role of duration of the carriage, predicting morbidity, or of other causes, to be explored.

Studies have reported that heavier backpack carriage in school children associated with fatigue symptoms(1), dorsal and low back pain(2), significant increase in disc compression and lumbar curvature(3), unable to recover from backpack induced lumbar lordosis following the removel of the backpack load(4), shoulder, neck and back pain and combination of bodily pain(5). Contrary to above findings, studies have also reported no independent relationship between backpack use and back pain(6), and active form of carrying backpack may decrease the odds of getting neck and back pain(7). Some authors have suggested regular optimal spinal backpack loading for healthier back and they cautioned back pain in children should be viewed from a biopsychosocial behavioral model rather than pure mechanical model similar to adult back pain(8,9).

Various factors such as physical, mechanical, psychological, social, environmental, ergonomic, socioeconomic, anthropometric and demographic characteristics are need to be examined before predicting backpack related morbidity in this population.

Although more studies are needed to explore to find a causal link between backpack use and back and neck pain due to heavier backpack carriage, the major unanimous concern is an urgent need to conduct longitudinal and prospective studies so that various confounding factors associated with nonspecific low back pain in children can be explored.

References

1. Kellis E, Emmanouilidou M. The effects of age and gender on the weight and use of schoolbags. Pediatr Phys Ther 2010; 22: 17-25.

2. Korovessis P, Koureas G, Papazisis Z. Correlation between backpack weight and way of carrying, sagittal and frontal spinal curvatures, athletic activity, and dorsal and low back pain in schoolchildren and adolescents. J Spinal Disord Tech 2004; 17: 33-40.

3. Neuschwander TB, Cutrone J, Macias BR, Cutrone S, Murthy G, Chambers H, et al. The effect of backpacks on the lumbar spine in children: a standing magnetic resonance imaging study. Spine 2010; 35: 83-88.

4. Negrini S, Negrini A. Postural effects of symmetrical and asymmetrical loads on the spines of schoolchildren. Scoliosis 2007; 2: 8.

5. Puckree T, Silal SP, Lin J. School bag carriage and pain in school children. Disabil Rehabil 2004; 26: 54-59.

6. Irene AY, Andrew JH, Karen SY. The association between backpack weight and low back pain in children. J Back Musculoskelet Rehabil 2006; 1: 25-33.

7. Haselgrove C, Straker L, Smith A, Sullivan OP, Perry M, Sloan N. Perceived school bag load, duration of carriage, and method of transport to school are associated with spinal pain in adolescents: an observational study. Aust J Physiother 2008; 54: 193-200.

8. Reneman MF, Poels BJ, Geertzen JH, Dijkstra PU. Back pain and backpacks in children: biomedical or biopsychosocial model? Disabil Rehabil 2006; 28: 1293-1297.

9. Lindstrom-Hazel D. The backpack problem is evident but the solution is less obvious. Work 2009; 32: 329-338.

 

Copyright© 1999 by the Indian Pediatrics (Disclaimer)