Original Articles Indian Pediatrics 2000;37: 1188-1193. |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Vitamin
A Status of Pregnant Women and Effect of Post Partum |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Manuscript received: September 23,
1998; Initial review completed: December 15, 1998;
Key words: Pregnancy, Retinol, Vitamin A deficiency, Vitamin A supplementation. The role of Vitamin A in critical periods of proliferative growth and tissue develop-ment, as in pregnancy, infancy and childhood is well known. During the period of early fetal development, however, the supply must be closely regulated to ensure that the developing fetus is exposed to neither too much nor to too little Vitamin A because both conditions can have adverse effects. Towards the end of gestation, adequate maternal Vitamin A status and dietary intake are important to maximize the Vitamin A transferred to the fetus in preparation for parturition and lactation(1). Breast milk is the only source of Vitamin A during the neonatal period for the exclusively breastfed infant. The ability to meet infant requirements depends on the concentration and the volume of breast milk consumed, both of which are influenced by maternal Vitamin A status and dietary intake. Infants breastfed by mothers with adequate Vitamin A levels are protected from Vitamin A deficiency(2). Recently, changing trends in Vitamin A deficiency in children below 5 years have been noted(3). Instead of older children (2-4 years), infants below 1 year of age have been observed to develop keratomalacia and this is attributed to poor maternal stores(3). The present study was undertaken to determine whether pregnant women from the lower socio-economic group have adequate Vitamin A stores and are able to protect their breastfed infants from VAD.
This was a planned prospective study carried out over a one-year period from April 1995 to March 1996. The study population comprised 109 apparently healthy primi and second gravida women in their third trimester, registered during early pregnancy at the antenatal clinic of a public teaching hospital. Pregnant women were included in the study after they had completed 34 weeks of gestation. Most of them belonged to the lower socio-economic group with ages ranging from 18 to 35 years. Pregnant women with illness likely to affect Vitamin A metabolism, those with clinical signs of Vitamin A deficiency, women receiving Vitamin A supplementation and those on oral contraceptives 6 months prior to conception, were excluded from the study. Preterm babies, sick babies and infants who were not exclusively breastfed were also excluded. Women were enrolled into the study after obtaining their informed consent. A detailed history was taken especially with regard to dietary patterns of intake of Vitamin A and Carotene rich food in the diet. The dietary history included the frequency and quantity of intake of selected food items rich in Vitamin A. These food items included dark green leafy vegetables, carrots, sweet potato, pumpkin, mango, papaya, whole milk, egg, liver, fish, meat and dairy products. According to the dietary pattern of intake of vitamin A rich food, women were catagorized as follows: (i) Regular intake: Consumption of at least 50 grams or more of Vitamin A rich food, 2 or more times a week; (ii) Seasonal intake: Intake of 50 grams or more of Vitamin A rich food available only seasonally; and (iii) Low intake: Consumption of less than 50 grams of Vitamin A rich food occasionally less than two times per week. Detailed clinical examination was performed on each subject. Serum retinol estimation was done on all pregnant women in their third trimester between 35-37 weeks gestation and on all cord blood samples. Five ml of venous blood was collected, the serum separated and transferred to cold resistant stopped tubes, which were then stored at 4º C taking care not to expose the tubes at any stage to light, as sunlight and artificial light decrease the activity of Vitamin A in the serum. Estimation of serum retinol was done by spectrophotometric method(4-11). After collect-ing the initial samples, the women were randomly assigned to two groups. The experi-mental group consisted of 53 mothers who received a single dose of 2 lakh units of oral Vitamin A (in the form of Aquasol water-miscible Vitamin A containing 50,000 unit per ml), within 48 hours of delivery. Aquasol was the preparation provided by our pharmacy free of cost for our patients. Hence this preparation was used in preference to an oil-based preparation. The control group comprised 56 mothers who did not receive Vitamin A after delivery. All babies were examined at birth. These mother-infant pairs were followed up for 3 months and monitored for exclusive breast-feeding. Twenty five mother infant pairs did not come for follow up. Among the 84 babies in our follow up, 4 babies in the control group and 3 in the experimental group had upper respiratory tract infection. Two babies in the experimental group had acute gastroenteritis with no dehydration. Stool examination in both these babies was normal. These minor infections were not considered to be significant. At 3 months the serum retinol of the infants and the breast milk retinol levels were estimated by spectrophotometric method. The procedure and conditions for the collection of the breast milk sample was standardized. Breast milk was collected in our newborn follow-up Outpatient Department between 8.30 am and 12.00 noon. Mothers were instructed not to breast feed their babies before coming to the OPD after the early morning feed and milk was pumped from full breast since the concentration of some milk components especially lipids and liposoluble substances such as Vitamin A increases during the suckling period. The milk was pumped with a manual pump from both the breasts by a trained nurse. After mixing, a sample of 5 ml was put into small plastic tubes with screw caps and covered with black paper (to prevent exposure to sunlight) and with ½ - 1 hour placed in a deep freeze at –20º C and then analyzed by spectrophotometric method. Serum retinol levles between 10-20 mcg/dl were taken as subclinical VAD. Breast milk retinol <30 mcg/dl was taken as boderline deficiency(5). The data was analyzed using the Student’s ‘t’ test.
One hundred and nine women, 86 primigravida and 23 second gravida were enrolled in the study. Table I shows the dietary Vitamin A intake and the serum retinol levles of 91 women whose sample could be analyzed. Twenty seven of the 91 women (29.7) had subclinical Vitamin A deficiency, all of them with seasonal or low dietary intake. Women with regular intake had no subclinical Vitamin A deficiency.
Table II shows the cord blood retinol levels of 88 samples which could be analyzed. Forty (45.5%) had levels between 10-20 mcg/dl. On comparison of cord blood levels with maternal serum retinol levels, 46 (63.9%) had lower levels, 10 (13.9%) had equal levels and 16 (22.2%) had levels greater than the maternal serum retinol levels.
Table III shows the comparison between the breast milk retinol levels in the control and experimental groups. In the experimental group 63.9% had levels >30 mcg/dl as compared to 30.9% in the control group. The lowest value in the experimental group was 20 mcg/dl.
Table IV
shows the serum retinol levels of exclusively breastfed infants at 3
months. A vast majority (97.4%) of infants in the experimental group
had normal serum retinol levels as compared to 55.2% in the control
group. Only one infant in the experimental group had a value of 20
mcg/dl.
Table V shows the comparison of the mean values of maternal serum, breast milk and infant serum retinol levels between control and experimental groups. The mean maternal serum. retinol level in the experimental group was lower but this difference was not statistically significant (p >0.05). The mean breast milk retinol level and the infant serum retinol levels in the experimental group were significantly higher than in the control group. Similarly, the mean values of the difference between the maternal serum retinol level and the breast milk level and infant serum retinol level were significantly different in the control and experimental groups. There was a decrease in the breast milk retinol and infant serum retinol levels in the control group.
Table VI shows that there was no significant difference between the mean values of weight and length at birth and at 3 months of age of infants between the control and experimental groups.
There has been a controversy regarding the cut-off value of serum retinol for defining Vitamin A deficiency. Most workers accept levels less than 20 mcg/dl as diagnostic with levels less than 10 mcg/dl closely correlating with inadequate body stores of Vitamin A and clinical manifestations of Vitamin A deficiency(6). Levels between 10-20 mcg/dl indicate subclinical Vitamin A deficiency(5). For this study, serum retinol levels between 10-20 mcg/dl were taken as subclinical Vitamin A deficiency. Ideally estimation of the retinol content in the liver best depicts the vitamin A status, but it is practically not possible to undertake such estimation. Though blood concentration of retinol is not a sensitive guide to an individual’s vitamin A status, low plasma values (less than 20 mg/dl) imply that hepatic storage of the vitamin may be exhausted. The proposal to use breast milk Vitamin A concentration as an indicator of Vitamin A status of a community is relatively new. It has the advantages of being non-invasive, readily acceptable and the sample is easy to collect. It is important to follow standardized methods of collection of sample. The borderline deficiency in a population is suggested to be <1.05 mmol/L or 30 mg/dl(5). In this study, 29.7% of pregnant women had subclinical Vitamin A deficiency, which is comparable to 31% reported from West Java(7). The mean cord blood retinol in our study was 23.98 mcg/dl which was lower than the mean maternal serum retinol of 26.5 mcg/dl. Other workers (8,9) have reported similar results. Higher retinol levels in cord blood than in maternal serum have been reported and explained by the concept of inversion(9). Nearly two-thirds (63.9%) of the mothers in the experimental group had breast milk retinol values ³ 30 mcg/dl as compared to only 30.4% in the control group. This suggests a definite beneficial impact of Vitamin A supple-mentation to the mother. By supplying adequate Vitamin A through the breast milk, the infant may be protected from Vitamin A deficiency. Venkata-chalam et al.(9) observed similar results of higher breast milk retinol values in the supplemented group. However, this supple-mentation was antepartum and the breast milk follow-up was only for 10 days postpartum. In another study, the breast milk composition of Vitamin A in Swedish and Ethiopian mothers was compared(10). In the non-privileged Ethiopian mothers, the range was from 28.1 mcg/dl to 33.1 mcg/dl which was similar to that seen in our control group (26.3 ± 6.76 mcg/dl). In this study, there was no difference in the mean weight and length in the infants in the two groups, at three months of age, suggesting no impact on the growth due to Vitamin A supplementation. In conclusion, this study indicates a high incidence of inapparent Vitamin A deficiency (29.7%) in pregnant women in the low socio-economic group. A single dose of 2 lakh units of oral Vitamin A given within 48 hours of delivery results in a significant increase in the breast milk and infant serum retinol levels at least for a period of three months postpartum. Contributors: VB initiated and designed the study, carried out the systematic reviews, collected and analyzed the data, and interpreted the findings. She will act as the guarantor for the manuscript. MNM initiated and designed the study, discussed core ideas and study design and contributed to interpretation of the findings. PS discussed core ideas, contributed to interpretation of findings and did the statistical analysis. Funding:
Department of Pediatrics, Lokmanya Tilak Municipal Medical College and
Hospital, Sion, Mumbai.
|