Benign recurrent intrahepatic cholestasis (BRIC) is a rare autosomal
recessive bile salt transport disorder, characterized by recurrent
episodes of pruritus, cholestatic jaundice with normal or low gamma
glutamyl transpeptidase (ggt). Bric and progressive familial
intrahepatic cholestasis (PFIC) represent two extremes of a continuous
spectrum of genetic intrahepatic cholestatic disorders. The exact
prevalence of BRIC still remains unknown. BRIC can present at any age
but usually before the second decade [1] with disturbing pruritus
as the primary symptom. Very few case reports have been published in
Indian literature [2,3]. We report the clinico-laboratory profile and
follow up of seven patients with BRIC seen over a period 20 years
(2000-2020).
Patient 1: A 16 year old adolescent boy, 1st born
to 30 consanguineous parents, presented with 2 weeks history of severe
pruritus associated with mild jaundice. His first cousin died of
cholestatic liver disease at the age of 7 years. On examination, he was
well nourished with icterus and scratch marks on his skin. There was no
hepatosplenomegaly. Complete hemogram and renal profile were normal. His
total serum bilirubin was 5.1 (direct:4.1) mg/dL, alamine
aminotransferase (ALT) was 133U/L, aspartate aminotransferase (AST) was
143U/L,
g-glutamyl
transferase-20 U/L, serum alkaline phosphatase-268 U/L, cholesterol -145
mg/dL and serum bile acids 491 mmol/L
(0.5-10). Prothrombin time was normal. USG abdomen showed normal liver
echogenecity and intrahepatic radicles were not dilated. Liver biopsy
was deferred due to refusal of consent. In view of the strong positive
family history of cholestatic liver disease, gene testing was done that
showed a single heterozygous missense mutation [c.1244A>G] in exon 13 of
ATP8B1 gene confirming BRIC type 1. He was treated with
rifampicin for 3 weeks, and at 5 months follow up, all his laboratory
parameters were normal.
Patient 2: A 16-year-old boy presented with
intense pruritus and jaundice for 20 days. There was history of two
stereotypical episodes of pruritus associated with cholestatic jaundice
in the last 1 year. During the icterus free intervals, he was normal. He
was second born to second degree consanguineous parents, and his elder
sister had been diagnosed as BRIC type 1. On examination, he was well
nourished with deep icterus and scratch marks on his skin. There was no
hepatosplenomegaly. Investigations revealed normal hemogram and renal
profile. Total bilirubin was 31 (direct: 25.3) mg/dL. ALT, AST and total
protein were normal. Serum bile acids were 350
mmol/L and GGT was 12
U/L. Magnetic resonance cholangiopancreato-graphy (MRCP) showed mild
hepatomegaly without intra or extra hepatic biliary dilatation. Liver
biopsy showed marked canalicular cholestasis, mild lobular inflammation,
with intact interlobular bile ducts and no fibrosis. He was treated with
ursodexycholic acid (UDCA) and rifampicin, and at 4 weeks his jaundice
had cleared. Genetic testing showed a homozygous missense mutation
[c.922G>A] in exon 10 of ATP8B1 gene confirming BRIC type 1. He
is under follow up for the last three years, and is doing well without
any worsening.
In the remaining five patients (3 girls) with BRIC
diagnosed histologically, the median age at onset of symptoms was 11
(range: 8-18) years. The cholestatic episodes varied with an average of
1 to 3 per year and the reported asymptomatic periods were lasting for a
maximum period of 3 years. There was history of consanguinity in 80%, of
which second and third degree consanguinity was seen in 50% each. One
child was adopted. Liver histology done in all five patients showed
intrahepatic cholestasis with intact interlobular bileducts and no
fibrosis. All were treated with UDCA, rifampicin and cholestyramine in
varying combinations. Over these 20 years, 2 girls got married and both
had pruritus during pregnancy. Another boy diagnosed with BRIC at 8
years was given complementary and alternative medicine for refractory
pruritus at 17 years, that worsened his liver function following which,
the jaundice deepened, bilirubin rose to 40 mg/dL and his INR reached 4.
He underwent 3 cycles of plasmapheresis, but succumbed to the illness
prior to liver transplant.
A typical episode of BRIC usually starts with
pruritus which increases in intensity and impairs the quality of life
followed by jaundice as seen in our series [4]. The symptoms may persist
from 2 weeks to 18 months before spontaneous resolution and asymptomatic
period may vary from 1 month - 33 years [3]. Low GGT, a hallmark
biochemical finding in this metabolic disorder in spite of clinical and
biochemical stasis excludes all the intra- and extra- hepatic causes of
cholestasis except bile acid synthesis defect (BASD). However, in BASD,
itching is not common and low GGT occurs with normal level of bile
acids. The characteristic changes seen in liver biopsy in BRIC are the
intracanalicular cholestasis with lobular inflammation without fibrosis,
which was seen in all the 6 patients, thus satisfying the diagnostic
criteria [5]. PFIC1 and BRIC 1 share the same genotype but have
different phenotypes, the former being universally progressive.
ATP8B1 gene is a translocator present on canalicular membrane of
hepatocytes and mutation leads to membrane instability and decreased
function of bile salt export pump thereby resulting in cholestasis.
Missense mutations are most common in BRIC type 1 [6] (seen in patient 1
and 2) and can either be homozygous (patient 2) or compound heterozygous
mutations (patient 1). However, Lee, et al. [7] have reported a
similar phenomenon of heterozygous frame shift mutation only on one
allele of ATP8B1 gene. Cholestyramine, UDCA and rifampicin have
been used in various combinations for the treatment of pruritus and in
our experience, neither cholestyramine nor UDCA worked well while
rifampicin alone gave a sustained relief in one patient. Rifampicin,
though considered as hepatotoxic, works well in BRIC by activating
transcription of CYP3A4, thereby stimulating hydroxylation of bile salts
and excretion at the basolateral membrane, thereby relieving pruritus
[8]. Endo-scopic nasobiliary drainage [9], biliary diversion procedures
[10], plasmapheresis and liver transplant have been suggested for
refractory pruritus.
This case series highlights the paradoxical
perceptions in diagnosis and management of BRIC, namely low GGT in spite
of cholestasis and use of rifampicin-a hepatotoxic drug, inspite of
underlying liver disease.
REFERENCES
1. Ermis F, Oncu K, Ozel M, et al. Benign recurrent
intrahepatic cholestasis: Late initial diagnosis in adulthood. Ann
Hepatol. 2010; 9:207-10.
2. Gupta V, Kumar M, Bhatia BD. Benign recurrent
intrahepatic cholestasis. Indian J Pediatr. 2005;72:793-4.
3. Chhetri D, Gupta R, Duseja A, Dhiman RK, Chawla Y,
Das A. Benign recurrent intrahepatic cholestasis (BRIC) in an adult.Trop
Gastroenterol. 2007;28:186-7.
4. Kumar P, Charaniya R, Ahuja A, Mittal S, Sahoo R.
Benign recurrent intrahepatic cholestasis in a young adult. J Clin Diagn
Res. 2016;10:OD01-OD2.
5. Luketic VA, Shiffman ML. Benign recurrent
intrahepatic cholestasis. Clin Liver Dis. 1999;3:509-28.
6. Klomp LWJ, Vargas JC, Van Mil SWC, et al.
Characterization of mutations in ATP8B1 associated with
hereditary cholestasis. Hepatology. 2004;40:27-38.
7. Lee YS, Kim MJ, Ki CS, et al. Benign recurrent
intrahepatic cholestasis with a single heterozygote mutation in the
ATP8B1 gene. Pediatr Gastroenterol Hepatol Nutr. 2012;15:122-26.
8. Srivastava A. Progressive familial
intrahepaticcholestasis. J Clin Exp Hepatol. 2014;4:25-36.
9. Choudhury A, Kulkarni AV, Sahoo B, Bihari C.
Endoscopic nasobiliary drainage: An effective treatment option for
benign recurrent intrahepatic cholestasis (BRIC). BMJ Case Rep.
2017;2017:bcr-2016-218874.
10. Metzelder ML, Petersen C, Melter M, Ure BM.
Modified laparoscopic external biliary diversion for benign recurrent
intrahepatic cholestasis in obese adolescents. Pediatr Surg Int.
2006;22:551-3.