Healthcare associated infections not only increase
neonatal morbidity, mortality, cost of health care and emotional burden,
but also prolong hospital stay and lead to resistance to antimicrobials
[1]. Infections significantly contribute to high neonatal mortality in
developing countries [2], and health care associated infections also
contribute significantly to this burden [3]. Newborns in the neonatal
intensive care unit (NICU) are more susceptible to such infections
because of their immature immune systems, fragile integumentary system,
need for frequent invasive procedures, and frequent contact with the
staff [4].
Health care associated infections can be reduced
significantly by strict compliance to hand hygiene guidelines [5]. Lack
of good hand hygiene practices is a single most modifiable cause of
these infections [6]. Adherence to hand hygiene is poor worldwide [1].
We planned to assess the completeness and accuracy of hand-washing
practices in NICU by analyzing video recordings.
Methods
The study NICU is a level 3 unit of a teaching
hospital in Gujarat, India, with 26 beds. It is managed by 7 nurses each
in 3 shifts (2 day shifts and 1 night shift). Six doctors are available
in the day shifts whereas 3 doctors are available in the night shift.
The hand hygiene policy of the unit is as follows: hand-wash with soap
and water before entering the NICU wards, alcohol-based hand rub between
patients, and hand-wash with soap and water between high-risk neonates
(extreme prematurity, sepsis etc). The inborn NICU ward has one sink
while the out born NICU ward has two sinks. Tap water is not
temperature-controlled and study was conducted in the winter months. The
taps can be operated by forearm/elbow.
Motion-activated video camera (Crystal IR) was
installed above the washing area of the out born NICU. Videos recorded
over a week (November 22-28, 2013) were extracted and analyzed by single
investigator with a pre-decided protocol, and information was entered on
the study proforma. Quality-check on video analysis was performed by two
senior investigators by random check. Hand-washing practice was
evaluated on the basis of Hand Hygiene Technique with Soap and Water
protocol of World Health Organization [1]. This protocol involves steps
given in Table I. Six main steps (step 2 to 7) were used
for classifying the appropriateness of behavior.
TABLE I Compliance to Hand-washing Guidelines
Step |
Particulars |
Correctly Done N (%) |
1. |
Wet hands with water |
1081 (100%) |
2. |
Apply enough soap to cover all hand surfaces |
1081 (100%) |
3. |
Rub hands palm to palm |
1081 (100%) |
4. |
Right palm over left dorsum with interlaced fingers and vice
versa |
489 (45.2%) |
5. |
Palm to palm with fingers interlaced |
1016 (94.0%) |
6. |
Back of fingers to opposing palms with fingers interlocked
|
874 (80.9%) |
7. |
Rotational rubbing of left thumb clasped in right palm and vice
versa |
437 (40.4%) |
8. |
Rotational rubbing, backwards and forwards with clasped fingers
of right |
1081(100%) |
|
hand in left palm and vice versa |
|
9. |
Rinse hands with water |
1081 (100%) |
10. |
Dry hands thoroughly with a single towel use |
Not assessed |
Hand-wash for <20 s was considered as poor
hand-washing practice (unacceptable). If three or more important steps
(step 2 to 7) were missed, it was also considered as unacceptable.
Hand-washing was categorized as excellent if it exceeded 20 seconds, and
all the six important steps were followed. The procedure was considered
acceptable if duration exceeded 20 seconds but only 4 or 5 steps were
followed.
Study was approved by the Institutional ethics
committee with waiver of informed consent. It was mandated that visible
information regarding video surveillance be placed. Descriptive
statistics [mean (SD), frequency (%)] and Chi-square test were used for
analysis.
Results
A total of 1081 procedures were recorded over a week.
The quality of recording was good and all videos could be analyzed. Of
these 1081 recordings, 775 (71.7%) were from nurses 204 (18.9%) were
from parents, and 102 (9.4%) were from doctors. Most hand-wash episodes
665 (61.5%) occurred during day time (8 AM to 8 PM). Not a single person
entered/exited the out born NICU ward without hand-wash.
Step number 10 was not applicable to our setup. Step
number 1, 2, 3, 8 and 9 had 100% compliance. Step number 4 (45.2%) and
step number 7 (40.4%) had very poor compliance (Table I).
Some videos revealed atypical behavior. Thirteen persons (11 nurses and
2 parents; 12 during night time) washed their face after washing their
hands. All these were classified as poor hand-washing. Out of 1081
hand-washing episodes, 37.3% were excellent, 48.2% were acceptable, and
14.5% were unacceptable. Only 4.9% procedures performed by doctors were
unacceptable in comparison to 10.6% by the nurses and 34.3% by relatives
(P<0.001) (Table II).
TABLE II Quality of Hand-washing in Different Sub-Groups
Groups |
|
Quality of hand-washing |
P value |
|
Excellent |
Acceptable |
Unacceptable |
|
Status |
Doctors |
73 |
24 |
5 |
<0.001 |
Nurses |
325 |
368 |
82 |
|
Relatives |
5 |
129 |
70 |
|
Gender |
Male |
69 |
27 |
9 |
<0.001 |
Female |
334 |
494 |
148 |
|
Shift |
Day |
283 |
298 |
84 |
<0.001 |
Night |
120 |
223 |
73 |
|
Discussion
In this study evaluating hand-washing practices in
NICU, we observed that 15% of procedures were unacceptable. Unacceptable
procedures were more common in night, and among parents of admitted
neonates.
The limitations of study were: short duration (one
week), and awareness of the personnel about them being monitored. Also
the study did not observe health care worker behavior after the initial
hand-wash. The study also did not analyze healthcare-associated
infections during the observation period.
Contrary to a study by Pittet, et al. [5] that
reported highest non-compliance among physicians, we found highest
compliance among doctors. The completeness and accuracy of hand-washing
was better in our study as compared to other studies in Indian setting
[1,7]. The high compliance in our study may be ascribed to team
building, empowerment of nurses, protocol-driven care and constructive
feedback to violators, all of which have been followed in this unit over
a decade. Multimodal interventions with ongoing surveillance have been
shown to be effective in an NICU setting [8].
The study shows good compliance to hand-washing
guidelines but also indicates scope for improvement with emphasis on
night shifts and parents. Innovative interventions may be required to
improve hand-washing behaviors during night shift, and among parents.