In the last two decades, there has been an increase
in the ownership of mobile devices like tablets, mobile phones, and
computers. The constantly improving networking service worldwide is
transforming the healthcare sector with the introduction of eHealth or
mHealth – the use of mobile devices for health research and delivery
[1]. Some of these include Facebook messenger, iMessage, Koo, Signal,
Telegram, WeChat and WhatsApp.
The coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) has disrupted
the conventional ways of practicing medicine and demanded socially
distant healthcare practice. Recently, the Government of India issued a
telemedicine guideline that said, "telemedicine includes all
communication channels with the patient that leverage information
technology platforms, including voice, audio, text and digital data
exchange " [2]. In this situation, WhatsApp came in as a handy tool to
consult not only for routine check-ups but also for consultation and
monitoring of COVID-19 patients [3]. The World Health Organization (WHO)
health alert service also uses WhatsApp to give people up-to-date
COVID-19 information.
Various scenarios show that using messaging apps can
accelerate communication, streamline workflows, enhance productivity,
and improve patient healthcare [4]. They help improve hospital
administration efficiency, secure hand-off, faster delivery of
laboratory reports, create a discussion thread with seniors and juniors,
and collaborate with those outside their workplace easily with seamless
integration of health records, and reach healthcare workforce in the
peripheral areas [4].
India is a developing nation, and doctors with
minimum access to large funds refrain from using professional EMR
platforms and use what is freely available and convenient. Platforms
like Magpi, Google forms, Survey monkey can be used to collect text and
numerical data but when it comes to collecting pictures and videos of
the patients, messaging apps are the most convenient option, in addition
to being used by researchers to send out survey forms to potential
participants.
Despite the benefits, the use of telemedicine has
always been concerning due to the lack of clear guidelines in India,
unlike some countries like the USA where a healthcare professional can
only use a HIPAA compliant platform for telemedicine. Third-party apps
like iMessage do not have access to user info, it is not the case with
WhatsApp business accounts anymore, making users migrate to other more
privacy-oriented appli-cations. Even end to end encryption poses a
problem as no data is being stored by WhatsApp (only saved locally on
the users’ device) which makes it nearly impossible to audit. With
messaging applications, it might become very difficult to keep a record
of patient data. If either user changes devices, it might lead to
complete loss of data unless a full backup is done prior to the shift,
which cannot be done remotely. Use of multiple messaging platforms by
various professionals may not allow crosstalk between them. Also, app
performance is in the control of the company, which may terminate or
modify it, based on corporate priorities.
In the current situation, messaging apps can also be
used for patient education services like by sharing links to reliable
sources of information. The acceptance of messaging is better if the
doctor and patients know each other. If it is the first consult, then
having a preliminary round of introductions may help build trust. Having
ground rules for communication such as when will the clinician respond
and the charges for communication via this medium, should be conveyed
early on.
Messaging applications can be used in the future for
regular follow up of patients. With the development of patient support
groups for chronic as well as rare disease using messaging groups would
be of excellent use. As capabilities of messaging apps get enhanced,
including artificial intelligence, there may be possibilities and
threats, which are difficult to foresee presently.
Acknowledgment: Dr Binoy Shah contributed to
the writing of the manuscript.
1. Langford AT, Solid CA, Scott E, et al. Mobile
phone ownership, health apps, and tablet use in US adults with a
self-reported history of hypertension: Cross-sectional study. JMIR
Mhealth Uhealth [Internet].2019;7:e12228.
2. National Medical Commission. Telemedicine Practice
Guidelines. NMC, 2020. Accessed June 2, 2021. Available from:
https://www.mohfw.gov.in/pdf/Telemedicine.pdf
3. Sabýrlý R, Karsli E, Canacik O, et al. Use of
WhatsApp for polyclinic consultation of suspected patients with
COVID-19: Retrospective case control study. JMIR Mhealth Uhealth
[Internet]. 2020;8:e22874.
4. Opperman CJ, Vuuren MJ van. WhatsApp in a clinical
setting: The good, the bad and the law. South African Journal of
Bioethics and Law. 2015;11:102-103.
5. Parikh PA, Shah BV, Phatak AG, et al. COVID-19 pandemic: knowledge
and perceptions of the public and healthcare professionals. Cureus
[Internet].2020;12:e8144.