We thank the reader for careful examination of our
study. The clarifications are as follows:
1. The formula used for comparison with JSS
Formula in our study was modified Shukla formula, which generally
falls short of JSS formula.
2. Though ultrasound is increasingly being used
to report the tip of the umbilical venous catheter, it is not
universal due to availability of machines/skilled personnel.
Regarding usage of lateral view, we differ regarding it being
better. We have recently conducted a retrospective analysis of 140
X-rays for inter- and intra-rater agreement between
horizontal-dorsal-decubitus (lateral) vs supine X-ray
in determining the optimal localization of the tip position. This
study showed a fair agreement (unpublished data) between both inter-
and intra-raters with supine X-ray (k=0.6) and poor inter-
and intra- rater agreement on lateral X-ray ( k=0.29).
3. We agree with the reader regarding the
possibility of migration of the catheter, and we did not collect
data for this time duration. The average turnaround time for chest
X-ray is approximately 30 minutes in our unit, and all X-rays
were taken with in an hour of insertion.