|
Indian Pediatr 2016;53: 635-638 |
 |
Leveraging
the National Rotavirus Surveillance Network for Monitoring
Intussusception
|
MA Mathew,*Srinvasan Venugopal,
#Rashmi Arora and *Gagandeep
Kang
From Department of Pediatrics, Malankara Orthodox
Syrian Church Medical College Hospital, Kolenchery; *Division of
Gastrointestinal Sciences, Christian Medical College, Vellore; and
#Epidemiology and Communicable Diseases Division, Indian Council of
Medical Research, New Delhi: India.
Correspondence to: Dr Gagandeep Kang, Division of
Gastrointestinal Sciences, Christian Medical College,
Vellore, Tamil
Nadu, India.
Received: December 31, 2015;
Initial review: March 26, 2015;
Accepted: May 05, 2016.
|
Objective: To assess feasibility of monitoring
intussusception by hospitals participating in the National Rotavirus
Surveillance Network.
Methods: Questionnaire-based survey in 28
hospitals. One hospital with electronic records selected for detailed
data analysis.
Results: There was 75% response to the
questionnaire. Few network hospitals were suitable for monitoring
intussusception in addition to ongoing activities, but there was at
least one potential sentinel hospital in each region. The hospital
selected for detailed data analysis of cases of intussusception reported
an incidence rate of 112 per 100,000 child years in infants. Over 90% of
intussusceptions were managed without surgery.
Conclusions: Selection of sentinel hospitals for
intussusception surveillance is feasible and necessary, but will require
training, increased awareness and referral.
Keywords: Complications, Rotavirus vaccine, Vaccine safety.
|
I ntussusception is a common emergency in young
children and has a peak incidence in infants aged between 5 and 7 months
[1]. Diagnosis is confirmed by ultrasonography, and it is treated by air
enema or hydrostatic reduction enema. Surgery is required only if the
pneumatic or hydrostatic reduction is unsuccessful. This condition is
also recognized as a rare complication of rotavirus vaccine, occuring
usually 3-7 days after the first dose in 1 in 20,000 to 1 in 50,000
vaccine recipients [2-4].
The risk of intussusception with the Indian vaccine,
Rotavac, is unknown [5]. The Rotavac vaccine has been introduced into
the National immunization program of India in four states from 2016. In
preparation for the introduction, the Indian Council for Medical
Research (ICMR), which has been conducting surveillance for rotavirus
disease [6,7], is planning to develop a safety and impact monitoring
system.
The objective of this survey was to describe the
capacity at hospitals participating in the ICMR's National Rotavirus
Surveillance Network (NRSN)–which were originally selected to enroll
children admitted with acute gastroenteritis to estimate the proportion
of rotavirus positive cases–to conduct surveillance for intussus-ception.
We also used available data to estimate the incidence of intussusception
in children in infancy and up to 10 years of age.
Methods
The 28 hospitals participating in the NRSN were sent
a questionnaire that included information on hospital location, size,
type of facility, availability of pediatric surgical services and
specialists, radiologic modalities, maintenance of hospital records and
available data on intussusception. Cases of intussusceptions in children
<10 years of
age seen at the Malankara Orthodox Syrian Christian (MOSC) Medical
College and Hospital at Erna-kulam in Kerala from April 2013 to April
2015 were reviewed. Data for each identified case, such as age, gender,
details of intussusception, and history of receipt of rotavirus vaccine
were collected by reviewing computerized admission records, surgical
records and radiology logs. All children admitted for intussusception
were included.
The survey data was compiled and stratified by
geographic region. The data from MOSC Hospital was summarized and
stratified by age. Details of the population of the region around MOSC
Hospital were obtained from the Demographic indicators report (2013),
Government of India [8]. We estimated that 40% of the population uses
the hospital for pediatric emergencies. The incidence rate of
intussusception was calculated using total number of cases divided by
total number of population at risk. A Poisson model was used to
calculate the 95% confidence interval (CI).
Results
Twenty-one (75%) of the hospitals in the network
completed the survey. The key descriptors of each hospital are included
in Table I. The data from the regions indicate that at
least one hospital in the Southern (MOSC Medical College Hospital,
Kolenchery; Om Hospital, Tirupati; and Christian Medical College,
Vellore), Northern (St. Stephen's Hospital, Delhi) and Western (Kore
Hospital, Belgaum; KEM Hospital, Pune; Lokmanya Tilak Municipal
Hospital, Mumbai) regions of the country already have records available,
and can record and analyze case data for sentinel surveillance of
intussusception. In the eastern region, it should be feasible to
establish surveillance at the Institute of Child Health, Kolkata in
2016. On the other hand, the survey data also established that some
hospitals would be unsuitable for inclusion in a surveillance network
because of the lack of availability of diagnostic and management
facilities.
Table I Description of Selected Hospitals Participating in The National Rotavirus Surveillance Network
Name and |
Type of |
No. of |
No. of |
Special |
Hospital |
Current |
location* |
facility |
pediatric / |
ped |
radiology |
records |
intussusception |
|
|
|
surgeons |
surgeons |
retained at |
records in |
|
|
|
beds |
|
hospital |
hospital |
East Zone |
ICH, Kolkata |
Govt |
160/37 |
2 |
US, MRI, |
Electronic from |
10 cases in 7 yrs |
|
|
|
|
no CT |
Jan 16 |
|
Assam Med Coll, Dibrugarh |
Govt |
130/35 |
4 |
US, CT, MRI |
Yes, no ICD coding |
4 in 1 year |
North Zone |
NSC Bose MCH, Jabalpur |
Govt |
72/30 |
2 |
US, CT, MRI |
Yes |
3 in 1 year |
SVBP Hosp, Meerut |
Govt |
60/20 |
1 |
US |
Yes |
No |
KS Hosp, Delhi |
Govt |
300/60 |
4+10 |
US |
Yes |
Unknown |
Hamidia/Kamla Hosp, Bhopal |
Govt |
140/30 |
3 |
US, CT |
Yes |
Unknown |
St. Stephen's, Delhi |
Private |
38 |
2/1PT |
US, CT, MRI |
Yes |
01/13 to 08/15=17 |
West Zone |
Kore Hosp/ |
JNMC Belgaum |
Private |
130/20 |
2 |
US, CT, MRI |
Yes |
08/14 to 8/15=47 |
Krishna Hospital, Karad |
Private |
120/20 |
1 |
US, CT, MRI |
Yes |
08/14 to 8/15=2 |
Civil Hospital, Ahmedabad |
Govt |
210/30 |
2 |
Referral |
No ICD coding |
20 in 1 year |
LTMH, Mumbai |
Govt |
175/60 |
8 |
US, CT, MRI |
Yes |
1/15 to 8/15=32 |
KEM Pune |
Private |
100/25 |
4 |
US, CT, MRI |
No ICD coding |
40 per year |
Bharati, Pune |
Private |
90/20 |
2 |
US, CT, MRI |
Yes |
19 in 14 months |
Shaishav Clinic, Pune |
Private |
75/10 |
Part-time |
US |
No ICD coding |
4 in 1 year |
South Zone |
Pragna Hosp, Hyderabad |
Private |
64/8 |
2 |
US |
Yes |
No |
MOSCMC, Kolenchery |
Private |
80/12 |
2 |
US, CT, MRI |
Yes |
04/13 to 03/14 = 46 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
04/14 to 03/15= 57 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
04/15 to 08/15 = 22 |
CMC Vellore |
Private |
160/32 |
8 |
US, CT, MRI |
Yes |
2013: 34, 2014: 32 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
2015: 21 |
SV Hosp, Tirupati |
Govt |
220/30 |
2 |
US |
Yes |
06/14 to 05/15=8 |
qPed surg-pediatric surgery, US-ultrasound;
*District Hospital, Dimapur (East Zone), SMIMER Hospital Surat
(West Zone), Child Jesus Hospital, Trichy (South Zone) are not
included as they refer all cases of suspected intussusception.
|
Data from MOSC Hospital – which provides healthcare
for over five million population from Ernakulam and Idukki district,
Kerala, with an average of 3000 pediatric outpatient and 800 inpatients
annually – showed that during the two year study period, there were 106
children (age <10 years) diagnosed with intussusception. The male-female
ratio was 1.9:1. All 106 cases were diagnosed radiologically, and 96
(90.6%) were reduced by hydrostatic enema, while 10 (9.4%) required a
laparatomy. None of the cases had history of receiving rotavirus
vaccination. All children recovered.
The average incidence of intussusception in children
<10 years was 29.8 (95% CI, 24.6 - 35.9) per 100,000 child-years, with
the highest incidence (112.9 per 100,000 child years) in the 6-12 month
age group (Table II).
TABLE II Estimated Incidence Rate of Intussusception Among Children (Age <10 Y)
At Mosc Medical College Hospital, Ernakulam, Kerala, 2013-2015
Age (in months) |
No. of cases (%) |
Time at risk years |
Population at risk |
Incidence rate* |
95% CI |
<6 |
13 (12.3) |
2 |
40870.61 |
39.8 |
23.1 - 68.5 |
6 - 12 |
40 (37.7) |
2 |
44289.87 |
112.9 |
82.8 - 153.9 |
13 - 24 |
16 (15.1) |
2 |
43351.75 |
46.1 |
28.2 - 75.3 |
25 - 60 |
29 (27.4) |
2 |
133378.57 |
27.2 |
18.9 - 39.1 |
61 - 108 |
8 (7.5) |
2 |
183447.66 |
5.5 |
2.7 - 10.9 |
Total |
106 |
2 |
445338.46 |
29.8 |
24.6 - 35.9 |
*Per 100,000 person-years; Incidence of Intussusception =
(No. of cases/Population at risk × time at risk × 0.40) × 100
000. |
Discussion
The survey of hospitals which were selected for
inclusion in the NRSN for their ability to recruit children hospitalized
with gastroenteritis showed that in major geographic regions of India,
there are one or more hospitals that can also serve as sentinel
facilities for intussusception surveillance. This is important because
fewer resources will be required if the same hospitals can be used for
surveillance for impact and safety when the rotavirus vaccine is
introduced into the Universal Immunization Program.
Only a few hospitals within the rotavirus
surveillance network were suitable for inclusion for monitoring of
intussusception, and most smaller hospitals refer children that may
require surgery. Management of intussusception at hospitals within the
network is undertaken only at hospitals that have pediatric surgery
services (Table I), even though reduction of
intussusception is increasingly without surgery. Monitoring of
intussusception, irrespective of when rotavirus vaccine is introduced,
requires ensuring awareness and appropriate referrals among healthcare
providers. Monitoring of the rate of intussusception following vaccine
introduction requires preparation of hospitals to accurately record
vaccination information for all cases of intussusception, which needs
appropriate investment in training and data capture. All of these issues
will need to addressed by the next iteration of the ICMR network, which
is now preparing for both effectiveness and safety monitoring.
The background incidence rate of intussusception
reported from MOSC Hospital is higher than the only other incidence data
from India, which is from Delhi, and was based on two cases in the age
group studied [9].
The limitation of the survey and this retrospective
hospital-based study might be lack of quality of documentation, and
incomplete clinical records. In terms of incidence, the rates may be
under- or over-estimated depending on the proportion of the population
accessing healthcare at MOSC Hospital. However, even at the highest rate
of 113 in the 6-12 month age group in Kolenchery, these estimates are
lower than reported for the whole period of infancy from other Asian
countries such as Japan, Vietnam and South Korea, where the incidence of
intussusception was 158, 296 and 326 per 100,000 child-years,
respectively [10-12].
Overall, information on intussuception is needed,
particularly when rotavirus vaccination is introduced, and the use of
sentinel facilities will support safety monitoring post-vaccine
introduction. However, promotion of awareness and rapid referral should
be emphasized to ensure appropriate case management of intussusception.
Careful recording of vaccination information will be needed to determine
whether cases are in the risk window following vaccination or not, in
order that vaccine associated risk is accurately estimated.
Contributors: MAM: collected and analyzed the
data; SV: analyzed the data and wrote the first draft; GK, RA: designed
the study, collected and analyzed data and revised the manuscript.
Funding: Indian Council of Medical Research.
Competing interest: RA heads the Epidemiology and
Communicable Diseases Division at ICMR.
What This Study Adds?
•
Hospitals participating in the
National Rotavirus Surveillance Network will be a valuable
resource to monitor safety after rotavirus vaccine introduction
into the Universal Immunization Program of India.
•
Surgical interventions are required in only a small
proportion of cases of intussusception, with most reductions
acheived radiologically.
|
References
1. Jiang J, Jiang B, Parashar U, Nguyen T, Bines J,
Patel MM. Childhood intussusception: A literature review. PloS One.
2013;8:e68482.
2. Haber P, Parashar UD, Haber M, DeStefano F.
Intussusception after monovalent rotavirus vaccine-United States,
Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS), 2008-2014. Vaccine.
2015;33:4873-7.
3. Rosillon D, Buyse H, Friedland LR, Ng SP,
Velázquez FR, Breuer T. Risk of intussusception after rotavirus
vaccination: Meta-analysis of post-licensure studies. Pediatr Infect Dis
J. 2015;34:763-8.
4. Escolano S, Hill C, Tubert-Bitter P.
Intussusception risk after RotaTeq vaccination: Evaluation from
worldwide spontaneous reporting data using a self-controlled case series
approach. Vaccine. 2015;33:1017-20.
5. Bhandari N, Rongsen-Chandola T, Bavdekar A, John
J, Antony K, Taneja S, et al. Efficacy of a monovalent
human-bovine (116E) rotavirus vaccine in Indian infants: A randomised
double blind placebo controlled trial. Lancet. 2014;383:2136-43.
6. Kang G, Desai R, Arora R, Chitamabar S, Naik TN,
Krishnan T, et al. Diversity of circulating rotavirus strains in
children hospitalized with diarrhea in India, 2005-2009. Vaccine.
2013;31:2879-83.
7. Tate JE, Arora R, Kang G, Parashar UD. Rotavirus
vaccines at the threshold of implementation in India. Natl Med J India.
2014;27:245-8.
8. Ministry of Health and Family Welfare (Central
Bureau of Health Intelligence: Demographic Indicators) 2013 Report,
Government of India. Available from: http://cbhidghs.nic.in/writereaddata/mainlinkFile/Demographic
Indicators-2013. pdf. Accessed November 13, 2015.
9. Bahl R, Saxena M, Bhandari N, Taneja S, Mathur M,
Parashar UD, et al. Population-based incidence of intussusception
and a case-control study to examine the association of intussusception
with natural rotavirus infection among Indian children. J Infect Dis.
2009;200:S277-81.
10. Noguchi A, Nakagomi T, Kimura S, Takahashi Y,
Matsuno K, Koizumi H, et al. Incidence of intussusception as
studied from a hospital-based retrospective survey over a 10-year period
(2001-2010) in Akita Prefecture, Japan. Jpn J Infect Dis. 2012;65:301-5.
11. Tran LA, Yoshida LM, Nakagomi T, Gauchan P,
Ariyoshi K, Anh DD, et al. A high incidence of intussusception
revealed by a retrospective hospital-based study in Nha Trang, Vietnam
between 2009 and 2011. Trop Med Health. 2013;41:121-7.
12. Jo DS, Nyambat B, Kim JS, Jang YT, Ng TL, Bock
HL, et al. Population-based incidence and burden of childhood
intussusception in Jeonbuk Province, South Korea. Int J Infect Dis.
2009;13:e383-8.
|
|
 |
|