Acute liver failure (ALF) is a rapidly
progressive, potentially fatal syndrome caused by a large variety of
insults. It is defined as presence of biochemical evidence of liver
injury (deranged transaminases) and coagulopathy not corrected by
parenteral vitamin K administration with International Normalized ratio
(INR)
³1.5 in
the presence of encephalopathy or an INR >2 with no evidence of
encephalopathy [1]. The etiology of ALF varies according to the age of
patient and development of the country [2-4]. The survival rate of ALF
also varies according to etiology – survival is better in few etiologies
like paracetamol poisoning whereas it is poor in metabolic diseases
[4,5]. Because of the shortage of facilities of liver transplantation
(LT), a large number of patients of ALF die without undergoing LT.
Determining the prognosis of ALF is vital when considering the patient
for LT so as to identify those patients who are unlikely to survive
without LT and assessing the probability of successful LT. The present
study was undertaken to study the underlying etiology and prognostic
markers of ALF in children under 18 years.
Methods
It was a prospective cohort study conducted in
Pediatric Intensive Care Unit (PICU) of a tertiary care teaching
hospital from November 2008 to March 2010 after obtaining institutional
ethical clearance. All consecutive children <18 years old, fulfilling
the case definition of acute liver failure were recruited [1]. Patients
with a past history of liver disease or features of chronic liver
disease on examination were excluded. After receiving informed consent,
the patients were subjected to hematological and biochemical
investigations. All patients were tested for viral markers for
hepatitis. Investigations for other infections like dengue, malaria and
enteric fever were conducted, wherever clinically indicated. All
children less than 1 year age were investigated for Galactosemia and
neonatal hemochromatosis; the former by detection of urinary reducing
substances and by Galactose 1 phosphate uridyl transferase assay and the
latter by serum ferritin levels. All children more than 1 year old were
screened for autoimmune hepatitis and Wilson disease (serum
ceruloplasmin, presence of KF ring and 24 hours urinary copper levels).
All the patients were monitored for hypoglycemia and were managed
according to the standard ICU protocols. This included maintaining fluid
and electrolyte balance, euglycemia maintainence, protein restriction,
bowel wash and lactulose. The standard treatment for clinical evidence
of cerebral edema included: head end elevation, maintaining normotension,
fever control, limiting non-essential physical examination, correction
of hypoxemia and hypercapnia by mechanical ventilation, and mannitol
infusion. Fresh-frozen plasma was infused for bleeding manifestations as
per standard recommendations. Broad spectrum antibiotics were given
empirically. Prognostic factors were studied by dividing cases into two
groups according to the final outcome: Group A comprised of those
patients who expired while group B comprised of those who improved and
were discharged.
Data were analyzed using SPSS statistical software
version 13.0. Univariate and multivariate analysis was used for
comparison
Results
During the study period 58 children were admitted
with liver failure. Fifteen patients were excluded due to past history
of liver disease or physical signs of chronic liver disease, expiry
within few hours of admission and refusal of consent. The study
population included 43 children (30 boys) with a mean age of 4.8 year.
Table I depicts baseline clinical and biochemical
characteristics of patients. Etiology was established in 39/43 (91%)
children (Table II). Infections were the most common cause
(77%) with viral hepatitis (hepatitis A-E) in 72% cases. 19 patients
(44%) constituted Group A and 24 patients (56%) constituted Group B.
Patients in whom the interval between onset of prodromal symptoms and
onset of encephalopathy was >7 days had a significantly higher mortality
rate (77%) in comparison to those with an interval of < 7days (34%; P=0.015).
Web Fig.1 shows the ROC curve plotted. An interval of >4.5
days was found to be predictor of mortality with a sensitivity of 77.8%
and specificity of 66.7% (Area Under Curve 0.718, P value 0.026).
Mortality rate increased in proportion to stage of encephalopathy. The
mortality in children with blood glucose
£45mg/dL was higher
than those with levels >45mg/dL. On applying multiple logistic
regression analysis, interval of greater than 7 days between prodromal
symptoms and encephalopathy and blood glucose
£45mg/dL were found
to be predictors of mortality.
TABLE I Difference in Clinical and Laboratory Parameters in the 2 Groups
Parameter |
Number |
Group A |
Group B |
P
|
|
N=43 |
(death) |
(discharged) |
value
|
|
(100%) |
N=19 (44%) |
N=24 (56%) |
|
Age |
<1 yr |
6 (14%) |
4/6 (67%) |
2/6 (33%) |
0.714 |
1- 5 yr |
19 (44%) |
7/19 (37%) |
12/19 (63%) |
|
5- 10 yr |
14 (32.5%) |
6/14 (43%) |
8/14 (57%) |
|
>10 yr |
4 (9.3%) |
2/4 (50%) |
2/4 (50%) |
|
Sex |
|
|
|
|
Male |
30 (70%) |
12/30 (40%) |
18/30 (60%) |
0.5 |
Female |
13 (30%) |
7/13 (54%) |
6/13 (46%) |
|
Bleeding |
|
|
|
|
Yes |
19 (42%) |
11/19 (58%) |
8/19 (42%) |
0.1 |
No |
24 (58%) |
8/24 (33%) |
16/24 (67%) |
|
Interval between onset of prodromal symptoms and encephalopathy |
<7 days |
23 (56%) |
8 (34%) |
15 (66%) |
0.015 |
>7 days |
13 (34%) |
10 (77%) |
3 (23%) |
|
Encephalopathy grade |
0 |
7 (16%) |
1/7 (14%) |
6/7 (86%0 |
0.001 |
1 |
5 (11%) |
1/5 (20%) |
4/5 (80%) |
|
2 |
12 (28%) |
2/12 (16%) |
10/12 (84%) |
|
3 |
14 (32.5%) |
10/14 (71%) |
4/14 (29%) |
|
4 |
5 (11%) |
5/5 (100%) |
0/5 (0%) |
|
Blood glucose |
£45mg/dL |
8 (19%) |
8/8 (100%) |
0/8 (0%) |
0.001 |
>45mg/dL |
35 (81%) |
24/35 (68%) |
11/35 (32%) |
|
Mean ± SD |
|
62.71± 24.73 |
89.17± 16.89 |
0.002 |
Total serum bilirubin(mg/dL) |
<10 |
18 (42%) |
4/18 (22%) |
14/18 (78%) |
0.014 |
>10 |
25 (58%) |
15/25 (60%) |
10/25 (40%)
|
|
pH |
|
|
|
|
<7.35 |
11 (26%) |
7/11 (54%) |
4/11 (36%) |
0.038 |
7.35-7.45 |
25 (58%) |
7/25 (28%) |
18/25 (72%) |
|
>7.45 |
7 (16%) |
5/7 (72%) |
2/7 (28%) |
|
TABLE II Etiology and its Relation to Mortality
Etiology |
Number |
Group A |
Group B |
|
N=43 |
(death) |
(discharged) |
|
|
N=19 |
N=24 |
HAV |
25 (58%) |
12 (48%) |
13 (52%) |
HBV |
2 (4.6%) |
0 |
2 (100%) |
HCV |
0 |
0 |
0 |
HEV |
2 (4.6%) |
2 (100%) |
0
|
Other infections |
2 (4.6%) |
0
|
2 (100%) |
HAV plus HEV |
2 (4.6%) |
0 |
2 (100%) |
Hemochromatosis |
1 (2.3%) |
1 (100%) |
0 |
Galactosemia |
2 (4.6%) |
2 (100%) |
0 |
Wilson’s disease |
2 (4.6%) |
0 |
2 (100%) |
Autoimmune hepatitis |
1 (2.3%) |
1 (100%) |
0 |
Indeterminate |
4 (9.2%) |
1 (25%) |
3 (75%) |
Discussion
Since ALF is a potentially fatal condition,
estimating the likelihood of spontaneous recovery and identifying
patients who cannot be salvaged without LT is necessary. Prognostic
factors that predict mortality and need for early LT are required. Our
study results highlight the fact that viral hepatitis remains the most
common cause of ALF in India. The presence of following factors was
found to predict mortality: subacute presentation, higher grade of
encephalopathy, higher bilirubin, hypoglycemia and deranged pH.
We were able to establish etiology in larger number
of patients as compared to previous studies [5,6]. Our results were
different from developed countries that showed that viral hepatitis
account for < 10% cases of ALF but are consistent with previous Indian
studies that showed that viral hepatitis is the most common cause of
mortality [5,7,8]. It highlights that the burden of ALF can be decreased
by decreasing viral hepatitis prevalence.
We also found that higher grade of encephalopathy and
<7 days duration between onset prodromal symptoms and encephalopathy
predict mortality similar to previous studies. [4,5,7]. Total serum
bilirubin has been proposed to be a predictor of mortality in various
studies [4,9,10]. We found that the prognosis of ALF worsens if total
serum bilirubin levels increase beyond 10mg/dL. Also, the mortality was
higher when indirect bilirubin was more than direct bilirubin, although
the result was not statistically significant.
Srivastava, et al. [9] proposed that
hypoglycemia (blood glucose < 45mg/dL) predicts mortality [9]. We also
found that hypoglycemia is an independent predictor of mortality. It
highlights the fact that early detection and appropriate treatment of
this potentially treatable complication can improve the outcome.
Deranged pH was also found to be a marker for poor prognosis similar to
previous studies [11].
INR was comparable in both the groups showing that
INR cannot be used as a prognostic factor in contrast to previous
studies [4,9,11] The difference in results can be explained by the fact
that the liver is the source of all clotting and anticoagulant factors.
This balanced reduction in both factors explains the relative
infrequency of clinically significant bleeding in ALF in the absence of
provocative factor like infection or portal hypertension [12].
As viral hepatitis was the most common etiological
agent, it highlight the fact that simple interventions like improving
hygienic practices and immunization coverage can substantially decrease
ALF. Our study carries various limitations because of the small sample
size and hence generalization of our study results needs further
research using a larger sample size.
Contributors: SK collected data, prepared the
manuscript. PK conceived, designed the study and revised the manuscript
for important intellectual content. VK and SKS reviewed the design and
revised the manuscript. PK, VK and SKS will act as guarantor of the
study. AK helped in preparation of the manuscript and analysis of data.
The final manuscript was approved by all authors.
Funding: None; Competing interests: None
stated.
What This
Study Adds?
• Viral hepatitis remains the commonest cause of acute liver
failure in Indian children.
|
References
1. Bucuvalas J, Yazigi N, Squires R. Acute liver
failure in children. Clin Liver Dis. 2006; 10: 149-68.
2. Acharya SK, Dasarathy S, Kumar TL, Sushma S,
Presanna U, Tandon A, et al. Fulminant hepatitis in a tropical
population: clinical course, cause and early predictors of outcome.
Hepatology 1996;23:1448-55.
3. Ostapowicz J, Lee WM. Acute hepatic failure: a
western perspective. J Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2000;15;480-8.
4. Dhiman RK, Seth AK, Jain S, Chawla YK, Dilawari
JB. Prognostic evaluation of early indicators in fulminant hepatic
failure by multivariate analysis. Dig Dis Sci. 1998;43:1311-6.
5. Lee WS, McKiernan P, Kelly DA. Etiology, outcome
and prognostic indicators of childhood fulminant hepatic failure in
United Kingdom. J Pediatr Gastroenterol Nutr. 2005;40:575-81.
6. Ostapowicz G, Fontana RJ, Scheiodt FV, Larson A,
Davern TJ, Han SH, et al. Results of a prospective study of acute
liver failure at 17 tertiary care centers in United States. Ann Intern
Med. 2002;137:947-54.
7. Poddar U, Thapa BR, Prasad A, Sharma AK, Singh K.
Natural history and risk factors in fulminant hepatic failure. Arch Dis
Child. 2002;87:54-6.
8. Tryambak S, Ganguly S. Etiology, clinical profile
and prognostic indicators for children with acute liver failure. Trop
Gastroenterol. 2007;28:135-9.
9. Srivastava KL, Mittal A,Klumar A, Gupta S, Gupta
S, Natu SM, Kumar R, et al. Predictors of outcome in fulminant
hepatic failure in children. Indian J Gasroenterol. 1998;17:43-5.
10. Squires RH, Schneider BL, Bucuvalas J, Alonso E,
Sokol RJ, Narkewicz MR, et al. Acute liver failure in children.
The first 348 patients in the pediatric acute liver study group. J
Pediatr. 2006;148:652-8.
11. O’Grady JG, Alexander GJ, Hayllar KM, Williams R.
Early indicators of prognosis in fulminant hepatic failure.
Gastroenterology. 1989;97:439-45.
12. Tripodi A, Caldwell SH, Hoffman M, Trotter JF,
Sanval AJ. The prothrombin time test as a measure of bleeding risk and
prognosis in liver disease. Aliment Pharmacol Ther. 2007;26:141-8.