1.gif (1892 bytes)

Letters to the Editor

Indian Pediatrics 2003;40:66-68

Professional Appearance of Pediatrician: Children’ and Pediatricians’ Opinion


Attire and appearance of pediatrician play an important role in the development of faith and respect in children and parents. Children might regard formally dressed doctors as competent and casually dressed doctors as incompetent(1). Recently, in an Indian study, Raichur et al.(2) studied the parents’ and guardians’ opinion regarding pediatricians’ appearance. We conducted a study to assess the children’s and pediatricians’ preference regarding pediatrician’s professional appearance.

One hundred children (age 8-15 years) brought to pediatric out patient department, PSG Hospitals, Coimbatore, during October and November 2001, were interviewed using a questionnaire containing 19 questions (Table I). First three questions were applicable to both male and female pediatricians whereas the next 6 questions were about the appearance of male pediatrician and the last 9 questions were about female pediatricians. Concurrently, the same questionnaire was sent to 50 pediatricians practising in Coimbatore city, to determine their actual habits and preferences.

Table I__The Questionnaire and Responses on Professional Appearance of Pediatrician

Question Applicable for both male and female

 

Children's Response

  
            

Pediatrician's Opinion

             

Yes          
(n=100)  
no no responses Yes (n=50)   no no           responses
1. Do you prefer a white coat on the pediatrician?
87
13
18
31
1
2. Do you think a name plate on the pediatrician
  preferable? 

77
23
33
16
1

3. Is it acceptable if the pediatrican uses perfume?
49
51
18
31
1
Regarding the male pediatrican: (n=100)     (n=26)    
4. Do you think a pediatrician can have a beard?
33
65
02
05
20
1
5. Should the pediatrician preferably wear shoes 
47
53
20
05
   rather than chappal?

6. Is it preferable if the pediatrician wears a neck tie?
50
48
02
06
17
3
7. Do you think pediatrician can wear T Shirt in the
46
51
03
10
15
1
   hospital?


8. Is it acceptable if the pediatrician wears jeans in 
44
55
01
10
15
1
   the hospital?

9. Do you think male pediatrician can wear jewels?
58
41
01
06
17
3
Regarding the female pediatrician: (n=100)     (n-24)    
10. Is saree the best dress for pediatrician?
73
25
02
17
07
11. Do you think pediatrician can wear churidar in
79
20
01
19
05
   the hospital?

12. Do you think the pediatricians’ hair should be 
18
80
02
13
03
8
   tied up?

13. Can pediatrician wear flowers in the hospital?
55
45
05
19
14. Do you think pediatrician can have short hair?
64
35
01
18
03
3
15. Do you think pediatrician can use lipstick in 
18
82
09
15
   the hospital?

16. Can pediatrician wear extra jewels in the 
30
70
01
23
   hospital?

17. Do you think pediatrician can wear anklet in 
66
33
01
05
19
   the hospital?

18. Can pediatrician use nail polish in the hospital?
58
42
11
12
1
19. Can pediatrician wear silk saree in the hospital?
43
57
08
15
1

 

Of the hundred children interviewed, 52 were males and 48 females; 62 children were from rural areas and 38 children were from urban areas. Younger children (aged between 8 and 11 years) were 52 in number and older children (aged between 12 and 15 years) were 48 in number. Of the pediatricians, 26 were male and 24 were female. Twenty three pediatricians were below 35 years of age and 27 pediatricians were above 35 years. Responses of children and pediatricians are summarized in Table I.

Physician’s appearance has been a topic of interest to medical historians. In a study by Barrett and Booth(1), majority of children and parents rated doctor’s dress as very important and children regarded formally dressed doctors as competent and casually dressed doctors as incompetent. Marino et al.(3) reported that parents had strong positive preference for formally dressed pediatrician and children felt negatively about informal attire. McCarthy et al.(4) had shown that majority of children preferred physicians in white coat. Gierdingen et al(5) found that positive responses from patients and physicians were associated with traditional items of dress and negative responses were associated with casual items of dress. Our study has shown that children and pediatricians prefer the pediatrician to be traditional in appearance. Majority of children prefer white coat, name plate, neck tie, saree, whereas they do not approve of beard, jeans and T Shirt for male doctors and lipstick, extra jewels, and silk sarees for female pediatricians. Pediatricians prefer name plate, shoes, saree, where as they do not approve white coat, beard, jeans, T Shirt, lipstick, flowers, extra jewels and silk sarees for themselves.

A.M. Vijayalakshmi,
M. Thinker Vel,

P.S.G. Institute of Medical Sciences and

Research, Coimbatore 641 004, Tamil Nadu, India.
E-mail: [email protected]

 References

1. Barrett TG, Booth IW. Sartorial eloquence: Does it exist in the pediatrician - parent relationship? Br Med J 1994; 309: 1710-1712.

2. Raichur DV, Deshpande RV, Chandragouda DK, Savitha D. Attire and appearance of pediatrician: Parents’/Guardians’ opinion. Indian J Pediatr 2001; 68: 413-416.

3. Marino RV, Rosefeld W, Narula P, Karkurum M. Impact of pediatricians attire on children and parents. J Dev Behav Pediatr 1991; 12: 98-101.

4. McCarthy JJ, McCarthy MC, Eilert RE. Children’s and parents’ visual perception of physicians. Clin Pediatr 1999; 38: 145-152.

5. Gjerdingen DK, Simpson DE, Titus SL. Patients’ and physicians’ attitudes regarding the physician’s professional appearance. Arch Intern Med 1987; 47: 1209-1212.

 

Home

Past Issue

About IP

About IAP

Feedback

Links

 Author Info.

  Subscription