Optimal COVID-19 vaccination strategy: Single dose
versus two doses
Over the last few months, there has been exhilarating
news of several vaccines against COVID-19 (Moderna, Pfizer and
AstraZeneca) with efficacy ranging between 70-95%. India too has
recently approved Covishield (based on the Oxford AstraZeneca vaccine)
and Covaxin (by Bharat Biotech) for emergency use. All these have
stirred hopes in our minds that a return to normal living could soon be
possible.
Most of these vaccines are given in two doses 3-4
weeks apart. Since the target would be vaccinating a majority of the
global population, vaccine shortage would be inexorable. Furthermore, it
is difficult to assure that those receiving the first dose would turn up
for the second. Vaccinating twice as many people with a single vaccine
dose would mean a better use of the available resources. Single-dose
vaccination seems more alluring as it is easy, less costly, and would
probably help in faster achievement of herd immunity. However, its
success would highly depend on the protection rendered by one dose of
the vaccine, termed single dose efficacy (SDE).
A recent study, using an age-stratified mathematical
model combined with optimization algorithms, ascertained the optimal
vaccine allocation with one and two doses of vaccine to reduce five key
metrics of disease burden (total infections, symptomatic infections,
deaths, peak non-ICU and ICU hospitalizations) under a varying
assumptions (different levels of social distancing, vaccine
availability, vaccine’s mode of action, vaccination rate). The results
suggest that optimal vaccination strategy critically depends on the SDE.
If the SDE is high, single-dose vaccination would prevent up to 48% more
deaths than a strategy of vaccinating the high-risk group first. If the
SDE is low or medium, mixed vaccination campaigns with one and two doses
of vaccine would be better.
At a time when we are unsure of the efficacy of
vaccines available, this study suggests that it is an absolute necessity
to promptly determine the efficacy of a single dose of vaccine to use it
optimally to end the pandemic and resume our routine activities as
quickly as possible. (MedRxiv preprint 5 Jan 2021)
Increased cooked meat intake linked to childhood
wheezing
Prevalence of childhood asthma has been on the rise
over the last few years. It has been found that dietary habits
established in early childhood may be associated with wheezing and
potentially the future development of asthma.
A study has suggested that certain substances in
cooked meats might predispose to increased wheezing in children. It
included 4,388 children aged 2–17 years from the National Health and
Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES) survey data. It was found that
higher intake of non-seafood meats and advanced glycation end products,
generated during high-temperature cooking of meat, was significantly
associated with wheezing, wheeze-disrupted sleep and exercise, and
wheezing requiring medication.
Although further studies would be needed to confirm
this finding, the study highlights these pro-inflammatory compounds as
early dietary risk factors for asthma. These risks are potentially
modifiable. This may have broad clinical and public health implications
for the prevention of childhood asthma. (Thorax 21 Dec 2020)
Novel imaging unveils if antibiotics reach cellular
targets
Antibiotics form the cornerstone of management of
infectious diseases. An effective therapy must incorporate drugs with
the propensity to invade all infected environments. This is particularly
important in cases where antibiotics have to attack intracellular
organisms. A thorough understanding of how effectively antibiotics
concentrate in various subcellular environments, and consequently target
the pathogen, is critical in the selection of the antibiotic of choice.
Researchers at the Francis Crick Institute, UK, have
developed a novel imaging method – correlative light electron and ion
microscopy in tissue (CLEIMiT) – to know if antibiotics have reached
bacteria within tissues. This was done by combining a variety of imaging
methods – confocal laser scanning microscopy, 3D fluorescence
microscopy, electron microscopy and nanoscale secondary ion mass
spectrometry. They analyzed lung tissue of mice infected with
Mycobacterium tuberculosis and treated with bedaquiline, and found
that the drug accumulated not only in foamy macrophages of the lung but
also in polymorphonuclear cells. This new approach elucidates the
subcellular localization of antibiotics and is a powerful methodological
advance to investigate if drugs reach their intracellular targets.
CLEIMiT is applicable to other drugs also, and
the researchers have continued their work on the technique, adapting it
for other categories of antibiotics. If we could select or develop more
effective antibiotics based on where they reach, it might help in more
effective antibiotic treatment, thereby reducing the duration of
treatment and the risk of antibiotic resistance. (PLoS Biology 31 Dec
2020)