reminiscences from Indian Pediatrics: A tale
of 50 years |
|
Indian Pediatr 2016;53:
147-148 |
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6ea7e/6ea7ecc87ce2ebba0a32f1ba047d7db7eefd5d3d" alt="" |
Mycoplasma pneumoniae A Tale of 50
Years
|
Preeti Singh and *Anju
Seth
Department of Pediatrics, Lady Hardinge Medical College, New Delhi,
India.
Email: [email protected]
|
The
40-paged February issue (1966) of Indian Pediatrics comprised of
four original articles, case records and a review of current literature.
Among these, we decided to review the article entitled "Mycoplasma
pneumoniae infection in an Indian child." At that time, M.
pneumoniae had been recently discovered, and it had generated a lot
of interest as a possible cause of pneumonia. Much has subsequently been
learned about this organism, and in this article we review the gain in
insight about this organism in last 50 years.
The Past
The reviewed paper [1] was a combined effort from
John Hopkins University Center for Medical Research and Training and
Institute of Child Health, Calcutta. It describes the clinical course of
an Indian girl with pneumonitis which was subsequently diagnosed to be
due to M. pneumoniae. It was only 4 years prior to this
publication that M. pneumoniae was successfully cultivated in
cell-free medium [2]. The investigations of this child were supported by
United States Public health service research grant from National
Institute of Health. The reported case was a 23-month old Bengali girl,
eleventh in birth order! She presented with a seven day history of
fever, coryza and progressive cough that was severe at night with a few
instances of post-tussive vomiting. There was a past history of repeated
upper respiratory tract infections. She was immunized only against small
pox. Examination revealed fever, tachycardia and tachypnea. The child
had cervical and axillary lymphadenopathy, hyperemia of nasal mucosa and
tonsils, and an injected tympanic membrane. The chest was hyperinflated;
the right lower chest was dull on percussion with diminished breath
sound. Occasional inspiratory and expiratory rales were heard over the
affected area. Cardiac examination was normal; the liver was palpable 5
cm and spleen 2 cm below costal margin. The chest X-ray
demonstrated a confluent opacification of the right middle lobe
consistent with alveolar pneumonitis and peribronchitis in the right
upper and lower lobes. Blood counts showed a neutrophilic leukocytosis.
Tuberculin skin test was negative and sweat chloride was normal.
The bacteriological study of the nasopharyngeal,
throat, per nasal tracheal aspirate, and percutaneous lung aspirate was
non-contributory, and virological examinations failed to yield a viral
agent. Meanwhile the child received treatment with penicillin and
streptomycin for 8 days. She became afebrile on 7th day of
hospitalization, and her respiratory findings, adenopathy and
splenomegaly disappeared while the liver receded to 2 cm below costal
margin. The throat swab specimen after being stored at 20
oC to 70 oC
for 27 days was examined for M. pneumoniae by inoculating on agar
plates and diphasic medium, and its growth was confirmed on the 7th day
of first agar subculture. On day 14 of incubation in diphasic medium, a
drop in pH (glucose fermentation) and spherular colonies were observed
floating in the media. The colonies demonstrated guinea pig erythrocyte
hemolysis (within 48 hours) and sheep cell haemadsorption, properties
peculiar to M. pneumoniae. Isolation of M. pneumoniae from
throat and tracheal aspirates of this child with pneumonia whose
extensive bacterial and viral investigations were non-contributory
indicated etiological role of M. pneumoniae. The child was
treated with demethyl-chlortetracycline. A repeat X-ray 3 month
later showed persisting middle lobe infiltrates, although child was
asymptomatic.
Historical background and past knowledge:
In the late nineteenth century, Nocard and Roux isolated the first
mycoplasma organism from cattle suffering from pleuropneumonia [3]. This
was followed by the discovery of other mycoplasma from various animal
species, which were termed as pleuropneumonia like organisms (PPLO). The
isolation of first human mycoplasma (Mycoplasma hominis) is credited to
Dienes and Edsall [4] in 1937 from a Bartholin gland abscess. In 1944,
Eaton and colleagues discovered an organism termed Eaton agent, as the
cause of pneumonia [5]. This agent was considered a virus till 1961,
when Marmion and Goodburn [6] described it to be morphologically similar
to PPLO. Eventually in 1962, Chanock, et al. [2] described the Eaton
agent to be a mycoplasma after its successful cultivation in cell-free
media. Shortly thereafter, he proposed the name Mycoplasma pneumoniae
as the organism inoculated in human volunteers produced pneumonia.
Kingston, et al. [7] established the therapeutic efficacy
of demethyl-tetracycline for M. pneumoniae pneumonia.
The organism was peculiarly known for causing cold
agglutinin positive primary atypical pneumonia in military recruits and
close population subgroups [8], but it was relatively uncommon in early
childhood. The isolation of this organism was slow and difficult,
serological tests were being developed and indistinctive clinical
picture did not itself lead to the diagnosis.
The Present
A lot has been learnt about its biological properties
since isolation of the organism in 1962. M. pneumoniae are now
known to be the smallest free-living ubiquitous organisms. The
pathogenicity in humans is attributed to the phenomena of cyto-adhesion
at the mucosa of the respiratory epithelium, impaired muco-ciliary
clearance and elaboration of a cytotoxin called as CARDS toxin that
damages the respiratory ciliated epithelial cells. In addition,
infection with M. pneumoniae induces production of
pro-inflammatory mediators and cytokines, which further exacerbate the
disease process. The ability of mycoplasma to internalize and replicate
in alveolar macrophages can lead to chronicity of infection and
resistance to antibiotics [9]. Recurrences are known to occur.
In contrast to the historic belief of occurrence of
M. pneumoniae infection among closed populations groups like
military bases and boarding schools, the infection and disease occurs
throughout the year punctuated by cyclical epidemics which are specific
to geographic locations. Pneumonia is the most important manifestation
seen in children aged between 5 and 15 years, while wheezing occurs more
commonly in under-five children. It is speculated to cause asthma
exacerbations [10], and can lead to decreased pulmonary clearance and
airway hyper-responsiveness even after the control of infection.
Even today, it is practically very difficult to
diagnose M. pneumoniae infection. Culture techniques require
specialized expertise, and are used only for research purposes for geno-typing
and anti-microbial susceptibility testing. Serological tests require
paired samples (acute and convalescent 2-3 weeks apart) for definitive
diagnosis. The detection of mycoplasma using cold agglutination test is
non-specific with limited diagnostic utility. The complement fixation
test, which was considered standard diagnostic tool till 2 decades ago,
has been replaced by rapid, single-specimen, specific antibody detection
(IgM or IgA) against mycoplasma antigens using membrane-based
enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays or immuno-flourescence. Specific IgM
and IgA responses need to be combined with direct pathogen detection for
establishing causation. Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) using numerous
gene sequences of M. pneumoniae as primers is a highly sensitive
and specific test to detect M. pneumoniae in various specimens
like respiratory secretions, blood, CSF and urine, but lacks validation
and standardization. In this setting, it is commendable that authors of
this case record could make a diagnosis of M. pneumonia infection
50 years ago!
For treatment of M. pneumoniae infection,
macrolides (azithromycin and clarithromycin) are now prefered in
children. The children and adult contacts are advised to follow personal
protective measures during period of infectivity till the index case
continues to cough. The trials for the development of vaccines are
underway, but still have a long way to go.
References
1. Hughes JR, Sinha DP. Mycoplasma pneumoniae
infection in an Indian child. Indian Pediatr. 1966; 3:52-9.
2. Chanock RM, Hayflick L, Barile MF. Growth on
artificial medium of an agent associated with atypical pneumonia and its
identification as a PPLO. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 1962;48:41-9.
3. Nocard E, Roux ER. Le microbe de la
pleuro-pneumoniae. Ann Inst Pasteur (Paris). 1898;12:240-62.
4. Dienes L, Edsall G. Observations on L-organisms of
Klieneberger. Proc Soc Exp Biol Med. 1937;36:740-4.
5. Eaton MD, Meiklejohn G, Van Herick W. Studies on
the etiology of primary atypical pneumonia: A filterable agent
transmissible to cotton rats, hamsters, and chick embryos. J Exp Med.
1944;79:649-68.
6. Marmion BP, Goodburn GM. Effect of an organic gold
salt on Eatons primary atypical pneumonia agent and other observations.
Nature.1961;189:247-8.
7. Kingston JR, Chanock RM, Mufson MA Hellman LP,
James WD, Fox HH, et al. Eaton agent pneumonia.
JAMA.1961;176:118-23.
8. Chanock RM, Mufson M, Bloom HH, James WD, Fox HH,
Kingston JR. Eaton agent pneumonia. JAMA.. 1961;175:213-20.
9. Dallo SF, Baseman JB. Intracellular DNA
replication and long-term survival of pathogenic mycoplasma. Microb
Pathogen. 2000;29:301-9.
10. Gil JC, Cedillo RL, Mayagoitia BG, Paz MD.
Isolation of Mycoplasma pneumoniae from asthmatic patients. Ann
Allerg.1993;70:23-5.
|
|
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d56fe/d56feb36a26bb258349b0ac18df7bc7d57977ffa" alt="" |
|