Whenever secondary schools permit students
to participate in the determination of the family-life education (FLE)
curriculum, information on sex, sexuality and substance abuse is almost
always demanded. For discourses on these delicate issues, schools depend
on the services of experienced teachers and doctors(1).
Cochin is transforming into a metropolis and the
influence of urbanisation is bound to change adolescent attitudes to
various issues. The Family Life Education Programs for schools in the city
need to be tailored to cater to the existing scenario. Hence, an analysis
of the issues that have been engaging the minds of adolescents in Cochin
over the past 5 years was undertaken to propose guidelines for the program
that would suit the requirements in private co-educational English-medium
schools in the city.
Methods
During FLE programs for classes IX and XI in private
English-medium schools in Cochin, school authorities were requested to
collect queries of students, on chits of paper without disclosing their
identity, a few days prior to each session. Students were also requested
to anonymously answer a pretested questionnaire (separate, for boy and
girls). The query chit papers were collected over the last 5 years during
36 sessions conducted in 7 Private Co-ed English-medium schools in Cochin.
Each session was attended by around 150-200 students. Three schools gave
consent to distribute the questionnaire. The queries and responses to the
questionnaire were analyzed in a descriptive manner. Responses by the boys
and girls were compared by chi-square test.
Results
The boys and girls together submitted 10660 queries;
multiples queries were received from 2289 students. The frequently asked
questions included that on masturbation (n=2278), sex and sexuality
(n=1684), academic problems (n=1545), substance abuse (n=1355),
psychosocial issues (n=922), pornography (n=877), and love
and infatuation (n=801). Queries also pertained to problems related
to parents (n=827), menstrual problems (n=241), and other
medical problems including HIV/AIDS (n=124).
TABLE I
Comparison of Answers Submitted by Adolescent Girls and Boys |
 |
Questionnaire response was submitted by 886 boys and
589 girls. Comparison of answers submitted by girls and boys to common
questions in the questionnaire are presented in Table I. The
answers to questions in the questionnaire exclusively for boys and girls
are given in Table II.
TABLE II
Adolescents’ Answers to
Questions n(%) |
 |
Difficulty controlling emotions, lack of person to
share and help out with problems, anxiety and feeling of sadness and
depression were the issues raised in 2%, 2.37%, 2.47% and 1.85% of the
queries, respectively. Twelve adolescents admitted, through the queries,
to be contemplating suicide.
Discussion
There is need for educating our adolescents on various
issues specific to their age group, through meaningful Family Life
Education Programs, and its importance is being realized of late(2,3). The
knowledge about menstrual hygiene, among girls in India, is
unsatisfactory(4). Therefore, sessions on menstruation for girls needs to
be dealt with at PTA meetings and in school by the fifth Standard about a
year before the onset of menarche in that social setup. Boys need separate
sessions to clarify myths regarding masturbation by the seventh or eighth
Standard as masturbation-related myths may be the most frequently harbored
anxiety among the male adolescent(5). Common source of knowledge about sex
and sexuality for children in India are their peers(6). To ensure that
they are provided with accurate and authentic information, lessons on safe
sex(7), reproductive anatomy, birth control measures and HIV-AIDS need to
be included in the curriculum(8,9). Sessions on substance abuse must start
by Standard VIII or IX as most children, who start smoking, do so by that
age(10).
Collecting queries on chits of paper from students, in
their own handwriting, a few days prior to a session is an extremely
useful tool in assessing the level of knowledge and the requirements of
the target group. The adolescents are able to freely pen their
apprehensions and fears and clear all their doubts. The disadvantage is
that students may not phrase the query as they actually intended to.
The pretested questionnaires are cost effective, can be
used for studies involving large sample sizes, allows introduction of a
number of research questions, reduces bias, is easy to analyse, familiar
to most students and most importantly, it does not make them
apprehensive(11). The limitations of using this method are a low return
rate and that the responses may not correspond with actual behavior.
Funding: None.
Competing interests: None stated.
References
1. Bhasin SK, Aggarwal OP. Perceptions of teachers
regarding sex education in National Capital Terri-tory of Delhi. Indian J
Pediatr 1999; 66: 527-531.
2. Grace FS. Some observations on family life education
in India. Marriage Fam Living 1963; 25; 466-468.
3. Thakor HG, Kumar P. Impact assessment of
school-based sex education program amongst adolescents. Indian J Pediatr
2000; 67: 551-558.
4. James, A. Menstrual hygiene study of knowledge and
practice. Nurs J India 1997; 38: 221-222.
5. Dhall A. Adolescence: myths and misconceptions.
Health Millions 1995; 21: 35-38.
6. Aggarwal OP, Sharma AK, Chhabra P. Study in
sexuality of medical college students in India. J Adolesc Health
2000; 26: 226-229.
7. Short R. Teaching safe sex in school.
Int J Gynecol Obst 1998; 63: S147 - S150.
8. Gupta N, Mathur AK, Singh MP, Saxena NC.
Reproductive health awareness of school-going, unmarried, rural
adolescents. Indian J Pediatr 2004; 71: 797-801.
9. Saksena S, Saldanha S. Impact of a course on human
sexuality and adolescence. Indian J Pediatr 2003; 70: 203-206.
10. Pradeepkumar AS, Mohan S, Gopalakrishnan P, Sarma
PS, Thankappan KR, Nichter M. Tobacco use in Kerala: findings from three
recent studies. Natl Med J India 2005; 18: 148-153.
11. Appleby JC. Additional Guidelines for Questionnaire
Design and Use. March 30, 1998 Available from: http://www.ucy.ac.cy/~kedima/KEDIMA_G
/QuestionnaireG/Material_Studies/newcastle_ design.doc. Accessed on
October 27th, 2008.
|