Many of the tests and interventions, which doctors
routinely carry out, may be unnecessary. The ‘Choosing Wisely’ campaign
is an attempt to reduce this. Each medical society is asked to suggest a
list of top five tests or treatments that doctors of their specialty
commonly overuses. This serves as a red flag to alert physicians to stop
and reconsider the test or intervention.
For example, in the ‘choosing wisely’ list of the
American Academy of Pediatrics Section on Surgery, the first is to avoid
the routine use of whole body computed tomography (CT) scanning in
pediatric trauma patients. This will reduce both radiation and costs.
The second is to avoid CT scanning as the first line modality to
diagnose appendicitis. They recommend use of ultrasound as the first
modality, and suggest use of CT scan only in equivocal cases. The third
is to avoid referring children with umbilical hernia to a pediatric
surgeon until the age of 4-5 years. The fourth is to avoid the use of
post-operative opioids in pediatric patients and use acetaminophen or
non-steroidal anti-inflammatory agents instead. The fifth is to avoid
routine fundoplication during gastrostomy insertion for children in the
absence of reflux. (Choosing wisely.org 4 November 2019)
Immunological Amnesia After Measles
It has long been recognized that after measles
epidemics, there would be a spurt of overall childhood mortality. The
reason has long been considered to be a measles-induced
immunosuppression. Now, immunologists from Boston (USA) have documented
how measles produces this immunological amnesia.
In 2013, there was an epidemic of measles in the
Netherlands. Blood samples of 77 of these children before and after the
measles episode had been preserved. Samples of children who had received
the MMR vaccine were also collected, before and after vaccination. Using
a new tool called VirScan, antibodies to various viruses and bacteria
before and after the measles attack were analyzed. It was found that
11-73% of antibodies had been erased after the measles infection. This
drop in antibody levels was not seen after MMR vaccine. This loss of
antibodies was due to measles-induced permanent damage to the memory
cells in the bone marrow. The authors suggest that revaccinating these
patients might help to rebuild the immunological memory and reduce
long-term mortality. The study is important in light of the fact that
measles infections worldwide trebled in the first half of 2019. (Science
1 November 2019)
A Vaccine to Prevent Tuberculosis
One-fourth of the world’s populace has latent
infection with Mycobacterium tuberculosis. These adults are a
reservoir, of whom 5-10% will go on to develop active tuberculosis.
Computer modeling has suggested that eliminating the infection in this
pool will play a major role in the global fight against tuberculosis.
A new vaccine M72/AS01 has now demonstrated robust
immune response in adults with latent tuberculosis. In a recent
randomized controlled trial, the vaccine or placebo was administered to
3575 adults with a positive interferon gamma release assay but no active
tuberculosis. On follow-up at 3 years, the incidence of
bacteriologically proven tuberculosis was 0.3/100 person years in the
vaccinated group versus 0.6/100 person years in the placebo
group. The overall vaccine efficacy was 49.7%.
This vaccine has also been studied in Gambian infants
who had received BCG vaccination. They received the M72/AS01 vaccine as
a booster 4-7 months after the BCG vaccine. Immune response in the form
of CD4 T cell activation and antibody production against M.
tuberculosis was found to be far superior in the group that received
the new vaccine. This vaccine marks a new strategy in the fight against
tuberculosis. (NEJM 29 October 2019)
Trikafta for Cystic Fibrosis
Trikafta is a combination of elexacaftor-tezacaftor
and ivacaftor. The FDA has now approved the use of this in patients with
cystic fibrosis above 12 years of age, and with atleast one delta 508
mutation. This follows two phase-3 trials published recentlyt. In one
trial, there was a 13.8 point increase in FEV1 after 4 weeks, a
reduction of pulmonary exacerbations by 63%, and a reduction in sweat
chloride by 41.8 mmol/L after use of the medication. In the other study,
Trikafta was used in patients homozygous for the delta 50 mutation.
There was a 10 percentage point improvement in FEV1 and 45.1 mmol/L
reduction in sweat chloride.
Elexacaftor and tezacaftor are called CFTR
correctors. They correct the processing and trafficking of the
F508del-CFTR protein, and enables it to reach the cell surface. In
contrast ivacaftor is called a potentiator. It increases chloride
transport by potentiating the channel-open probability. The combination
of these three drugs is being described as a major breakthrough in the
therapy of cystic fibrosis. (Lancet October 31 2019; NEJM November 7
2019)