Rectal or axillary temperature has been considered the
gold standard for measuring core temperature, although there are obvious
limitations to this procedure. The usual recommendation is to keep the low
reading mercury thermometer (25°C/77°F) for 3-5 minutes in axilla or
groin(1,2). The time required to obtain a stabilized reading as documented
in western literature using a digital thermometer is about 30-45 seconds
at either side(3). But there is no study published in our setup regarding
this.
In this hospital based, prospective, cohort study, all
neonates of any gestation or mode of delivery after initial stabilization
(preferably within 1 hour of birth) without congenital anomalies or any
sickness or distress were examined in Brazelton stage between I to III.
Electronic Thermometer used was Dr.Morgan Digital model MT-219. Vega
Technologies Inc. Taipei, Taiwan. An ordinary mercury skin thermometer
(Hick’s) was also used.
Duration of study was from October 2007 to August 2008.
Total 100 neonates were examined and data analysed. Both the thermometers
were simultaneously used-one in either axilla of the neonate. The stop
watch was started immediately after placing them. The Hick’s thermometer
was kept for 3 minutes and temperature was documented. The electronic
thermometer was removed and stop watch locked as soon as the steady beep
was heard and temperature and time needed were both documented. The
environmental temperature was also documented.
The mean time required for documenting a temperature by
a electronic thermometer in axilla was 56.34±1.54 for term neonates
(>2500g) and 54.87±1.23 secs for low birth weight (<2500g). The time
required for documenting temperature did not change significantly (P<0.01)
with environmental temperature. The skin temperature measured by the
ordinary mercury thermometer did not differ significantly from that noted
by keeping the electronic one (P< 0.01).
The present study is limited due to small study
population. And that may be the cause of higher mean time in our study
(56.34±1.54 s) than reported in western literature (30-45 s). But using an
electronic thermometer (Rs 200/-) instead of an ordinary one (Rs 60/-)
will save valuable time ( about >2min) for a peripheral health worker who
has to manage all resuscitation procedures single-handedly.
References
1. Deorari A. Neonatal hypothermia In : Dadhich JP ,
Paul V, editors: Newborn Care Practice and Care Settings; State of India’s
children; 1st ed. New Delhi. NNF India. 2004; p 65-71.
2. Bliss HJ. Comparison of rectal, axillary, and
inguinal temperatures in full term newborn infants. Nurs Res 1989; 38:
85-88.
3. Miller CA and Thomas BN; Routine newborn care. In:
Tauesch HW, Ballard RA, Gleason CA. Avery’s Diseases of the Newborn.
Philadelphia: Saunders 2005; 26: 323-338.