|
Indian Pediatr 2014;51:
621-625 |
 |
Effects of Elevated Blood Lead Levels in
Preschool Children in Urban Vellore
|
Venkata Raghava Mohan, #Srujan
Sharma, $Karthikeyan
Ramanujam, $Sudhir
Babji, ^Beena
Koshy,
**Joseph
Dian Bondu, *Sushil
Mathew John, and $Gagandeep
Kang
From Departments of Community Health, #Surgery, $Gastrointestinal
Sciences, ^Developmental Pediatrics, ** Clinical
Biochemistry and *Low Cost Effective Care Unit, Christian
Medical College, Vellore. Tamil Nadu.
Correspondence to: Dr Venkata Raghava Mohan, Department of Community
Health, Christian Medical College, Vellore 632 002, Tamil Nadu, India.
Email: [email protected]
Received: October 03, 2013;
Initial review: November 18, 2013;
Accepted: May 13, 2014.
|
Objectives: To study the burden and associated risk factors for
elevated blood lead levels among pre-school children (15-24 months) in
urban Vellore, and to study its effects on child cognition and anemia.
Design: An investigative study through Mal-ED
cohort.
Setting: Eight adjacent urban slums in Vellore,
Tamil Nadu.
Participants: 251 babies recruited through Mal-ED
Network.
Outcome measures: Blood lead levels using
Graphite Furnace Atomic Absorption Spectrophotometry method at 15 and 24
mo; hemoglobin estimation by azidemethemoglobin method; cognitive levels
using Bayley Scales of Infant Development III.
Results: Around 45% of children at 15 months and
46.4% at 24 months had elevated blood lead levels (>10 µg/dL). Among
children who had elevated blood lead levels at 15 months, 69.2% (45/65)
continued to have elevated levels at 24 months. After adjusting for
potential confounders, children from houses having a piped drinking
water supply and houses with mud or clay floors were at significantly
higher risk of having elevated blood lead levels at 15 months. Thirty
one percent (21/67) of the children with elevated blood lead levels had
poor cognitive scores. Children with elevated blood lead levels at 15
months had higher risk (Adjusted OR 1.80; 95% CI 0.80 - 3.99) of having
poorer cognitive scores at 24 months. More than half of the children
(57%) were anemic at 15 months of age, and elevated blood lead levels
were not significantly associated with anemia.
Conclusions: Elevated blood lead levels are
common among preschool children living in urban slums of Vellore. Poorer
conditions of the living environment are associated with elevated lead
levels.
Keywords: Anemia, Cognition, Lead poisoning.
|
Lead exposure during childhood
contributes to
intellectual disability among children.
Absorption of ingested lead is higher in
children with nutritional deficiencies, and pica further enhances the
absorption rate [1-3]. Children are more vulnerable to the toxic effects
of lead even with low levels of exposure potentially causing serious and
possible irreversible neurological damage. Lead exposure is also known
to adversely affect the behavior and cognitive development among
children [3-5]. Younger age and pre-existing iron deficiency pose
increased risk of developing lead-induced anemia. The prevalence and
severity of lead induced anemia is known to correlate well with blood
lead levels (BLL) [6-8].
This study aimed to investigate the proportion of
children with elevated BLLs and associated risk factors for elevated
BLLs at 15 and 24 months among the Mal-ED cohort in Vellore, India. The
effects of elevated blood lead levels on child cognition and anemia
among pre-school children were also assessed.
Methods
Vellore is a large town in Southern India located 120
km from the Tamilnadu State capital Chennai. As part of a multi-country
study on malnutrition, a birth cohort (called the Mal-ED) was recruited
from an urban slum of 8 neighbourhoods with an approximate population of
12,000 to be followed up at home, and at a clinic in the study area by a
team of trained field workers, nutritionists, psychologists and medical
staff.
Pregnant women residing in an urban slum were
identified through a house-to-house survey, and information on the
expected date of delivery was obtained. Mothers were visited soon after
birth and invited to participate in the study. Exclusion criteria were:
multiple pregnancies, another sibling in the study or family planning to
migrate outside study area.
Socio-economic status (SES) of the families was
assessed at 6 monthly intervals after recruitment using the following
components: access to improved water and sanitation, assets owned by the
family, maternal education and income (the WAMI index). The households
were further classified as belonging to low, middle or high SES based on
tertiles of the total score.
The risk factors tested included sex of the
child, low birth weight, duration of exclusive breastfeeding, maternal
anthropometry two months after childbirth, maternal mental status, and
(as collected by a SRQ-20 questionnaire), number of living children in
the family, any previous child death in the family, socioeconomic
status, and housing indicators, including the type of floor, walls and
drinking water. The association between socio-demographics, associated
risk factors and elevated BLLs was tested using a multivariate backward
conditional logistic regression analysis to adjust for confounding
factors; adjusted ORs were estimated.
Blood lead levels: A maximum of 5 mL of venous
blood was collected from the children at 7, 15 and 24 months for various
biochemical tests, of which around 1 mL of whole blood was preserved
with Dipotassium Ethylenediamine-tetraacetic acid (K2 EDTA) for
determination of lead levels. The samples were refrigerated immediately,
and were transported to the laboratory within a few hours using cold
packs. Lead levels in whole blood were estimated by Graphite Furnace
Atomic Absorption Spectroscopy (GFAAS) method using an M Series Atomic
Absorption Spectro-photometer. A value of 10 µg/dL was considered as the
cut-off level to identify elevated BLLs.
Cognition, motor, language, social-emotional and
adaptive behaviours were assessed using the Bayley Scales of Infant
Development III (BSID III) [9,10] at 6, 15 and 24 months. BLLs at 15
months were correlated with cognition scores at 24 months, as recorded
by the BSID-III.
Hemoglobin (Hb) estimation by azidemethemoglobin
method was done at 7, 15 and 24 months using a Hemocue
at the study clinic. The severity of anemia was
graded using the World Health Organisation’s Hb cut-offs of mild (10 to
10.9 g/dL), moderate (8 to 9.9 g/dL) and severe anaemia (less than 8 g/dL)
[11,12]. Associations between anemia at 15 months, child’s cognition at
24 months and elevated 15-month BLLs were tested using Chi-squared test.
Results
A total of 301 mothers were visited soon after child
birth and invited to participate in the study, thereby enrolling 251
children between March 2010 and February 2012. Ten mothers were
unwilling to participate and 40 babies were excluded. Of the enrolled
251 children, 25 were lost to follow-up due to non-participation (8),
migration (15), and death (2). The mean (SD) birth weight of the cohort
was 2.82 (0.44) kg; 124 (56%) were girls.
Seventeen percent of babies were low birth weight and
majority (62%) were exclusively breastfed for less than 4 months. Over a
third (82/226) of mothers were either uneducated or studied till 5th
grade. The mean (SD) maternal body mass index (BMI) was 22 (3.98) kg/m 2
and 41% of the mothers were either underweight, overweight or obese (Table
I). Less than one-third (69/226) of the children were from lower
socio-economic strata.
TABLE I Risk Factors for Elevated Blood Lead Levels at 15 Months Among the Study Children
Risk factor |
Blood Lead Level |
Unadjusted OR |
Adjusted OR
|
|
Elevated, No. (%)
|
Normal, No. (%)
|
|
(95% CI) |
|
(n = 102) |
(n = 124) |
|
|
Males |
47 (46.1) |
55 (44.4) |
1.07 |
1.09 (0.61 - 1.94) |
Low birth weight (<2500 g) |
16 (16.2) |
21 (17.2) |
0.93 |
1.36 (0.60 - 3.07) |
Exclusive breastfeeding <4 mo |
60 (59.4) |
79 (64.2) |
0.81 |
0.92 (0.50 - 1.70) |
Maternal age <24 y |
50 (49.5) |
57 (46.3) |
1.13 |
1.62 (0.87 - 3.03) |
SRQ score of >10 at 6 mo |
15 (14.7) |
25 (20.2) |
0.68 |
0.68 (0.30 - 1.53) |
Overweight or obese mothers (BMI ³25) |
28 (28.3) |
21 (18.3) |
1.76 |
1.84 (0.91 - 3.73) |
>2 living children in the family |
67 (66.3) |
71 (57.7) |
1.34 |
1.58 (0.88 - 2.86) |
Any child death in the family |
09 (8.9) |
07 (5.7) |
1.62 |
1.02 (0.29 - 3.64) |
Low SES (WAMI <33rd centile) |
33 (32.4) |
36 (29.0) |
1.28 |
1.14 (0.56 - 2.33) |
Piped water supply |
11 (10.8) |
06 (4.8) |
2.38 |
3.68† (1.10 - 12.40) |
Mud/clay floor of the house
|
11 (10.8)* |
03 (2.4) |
4.87# |
5.14† (1.30 - 20.17) |
Mud walls in the house
|
17 (16.7) |
19 (15.3) |
1.1 |
0.77 (0.33 - 1.81) |
*P<0.05, Chi-square test; #P<0.05,
Bivariate analysis; †P<0.05, Multivariate
logistic regression. |
Water supplied through public taps by the local
municipality was commonly (85.5%) used for drinking and less than 10% of
the houses had piped water supply into their yards or dwellings. Around
16% of the houses had mud walls and 6% of them had floors made of mud,
clay or sand.
A total of 226 blood samples were tested for lead
levels at 15 months, and 138 blood samples at 24 months. The mean (SD)
BLLs were 10.3 (5.0) and 11.8 µg/dL (8.6) at 15 and 24 months,
respectively. The BLLs (µg/dL) ranged between 2.4 to 29.7 at 15 months,
and between 1.5 and 66.8 at 24 months. Around 45% of children at 15
months and 46.4% at 24 months had BLLs over 10 µg/dL. Nearly 15% of
children at 15 months and 24 months had BLL >15 µg/dL. The 24 months
BLLs had a significant positive correlation with the 15 month BLLs
(Spearman’s rho of 0.37;P<0.01). Among children who had elevated
BLLs at 15 months, 69.2% (45/65) continued to have elevated BLLs at 24
months, while 26% (19/73) of children without elevated 15 month BLLs
subsequently had elevated levels at 24 months.
After adjusting for selected variables from the
univariate analysis, children from houses having a piped drinking water
supply, and houses with mud or clay floors were at significantly higher
risk of having elevated BLLs at 15 months (Table I).
Cognitive function was assessed using the Bayley’s
scale on 143 children at 24 months. The mean (SD) cognitive score was
60.6 (3.2). Cognitive scores at 24 months were negatively correlated
with the BLLs at 15 months; however, this was not statistically
significant (P=0.23). After adjusting for sex of the child, birth
weight, SES, maternal education and sibling death in the family,
children with elevated BLLs at 15 months did not have significantly
higher risk (OR 1.80; 95% CI 0.80 - 3.99) of having poorer cognitive
scores at 24 months (Table II).
TABLE II Multivariate Logistic Regression Model of Effect of Elevated 15 Month Blood Lead Levels on Cognition at 24 Months
Risk factor |
Poor cognitive scores
|
Better cognitive scores |
Adjusted OR
|
|
(< 33rd centile) (n=36) |
(³33rd centile) (n=107) |
(95% CI) |
Elevated (>10µg/dL) BLL at 15 mo
|
21 (58.3) |
46 (43.0) |
1.84 (0.83-4.08) |
Males |
16 (44.4) |
56 (49.5) |
0.76 (0.35-1.68) |
Low birth weight (<2500 g) |
8 (22.2) |
21 (20.2) |
1.15 (0.44-2.98) |
Maternal education (up to 5th grade) |
12 (33.3) |
35 (32.7) |
1.11 (0.40-3.08) |
Any child death in the family |
5 (13.9) |
5 (4.8) |
3.00 (0.75-11.92) |
Low SES (< 33rd centile; based on WAMI index) |
10 (27.8) |
30 (28.0) |
0.89 (0..2-2.53) |
The mean (SD) hemoglobin level among the study
children was 10.6 (1.3) g/dL at 15 months. More than half of the
children (57%) were anemic at 15 months of age. Hemoglobin levels and
BLLs at 15 months were not significantly correlated (P>0.05).
Children with low BLLs had higher proportions of anaemia across all
categories (Table III).
TABLE III Anemia and Blood Lead Levels at 15 Months of Age
Category |
BLL <10 µg/dL |
BLL ≥10µg/dL
|
Overall
|
|
No.(%)
|
No.(%)
|
|
No anemia |
51 (52.6) |
46 (47.4) |
97 (43.5) |
Mild anemia
|
39 (55.7) |
31 (44.3) |
70 (31.4) |
Moderate anemia
|
24 (51.1) |
23 (48.9) |
47 (21) |
Severe anemia
|
08 (89) |
01 (11) |
9 (4) |
Overall |
122 (54.7) |
101 (45.3) |
223 |
Discussion
In this prospective observational study from urban
Vellore, nearly half of the children had elevated BLLs at 15 and 24
months of age. Having a piped water supply and mud or clay floors in the
house were significantly associated with elevated BLLs. Proportion of
children with poor cognitive performance was higher among the group with
elevated BLLs but there was no significant association between elevated
BLLs and childhood anaemia.
Lack of detailed information on child rearing
practices and behaviors, and exposures pertaining to outdoor environment
were potential limitations. The Centers for Disease Control (CDC) had
earlier defined an elevated BLL as ³10
µg/dL for children under 6 years of age [4]. Recently, the CDC has
updated the ‘level of concern’ for BLL among children to >5 µg/dL. This
cut-off is based on the upper reference interval value of the 97.5th
percentile of the distribution of the combined 2007-2008 and 2009-2010
cycles of the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES)
in the United States. Since most of the available information is based
on the the earlier cut-off value, this study used a value of >10 µg/dL
to identify elevated BLLs.
Proportion of preschool children with elevated BLLs
in this region is higher than the values reported earlier from most
parts of India (12 to 38%) [13,14]. A study done among older children
from urban areas of Chennai has reported even higher prevalence of 52.5%
[15]. Only a few studies are available from India looking at family
demographics and environmental factors that might correlate with BLLs
among children. Educational status of the parents, age and sex of the
children, lower SES, total number of children born to the mother and
weight/height £95th
percentile are established risk factors in the developing countries. Age
of the house, materials used for flooring inside the house, piped water
supply, duration of occupancy or painting a residence are some of the
important environmental predictors associated with elevated BLLs
[8,16,17].
An association between early childhood lead levels
and cognitive impairment at a later age is well documented [18-20].
Evidence from a systematic review indicates that doubling of BLL is
associated with a mean deficit in the full scale IQ by 1 to 2 points
[21]. A study among urban children aged 3 to 7 years from Chennai,
India, found that high BLLs were associated with reduced visual-motor
abilities [15]. In our study, children with elevated BLLs at 15 months
had excess risk of having poorer cognitive scores at 24 months although
this finding was not statistically significant. Future prospective
assessments of cognition and school performances are needed to better
understand the effect of lead exposure on neurodevelopment of children.
Younger age and pre-existing iron deficiency pose increased risk of
developing lead induced clinical anemia. Anemia has been reported to be
more common among children below 3 years of age with high BLLs (75.3 %
vs. 67.4 %) [17]. In our study, more than half of the study
children were anemic at 15 months of age but significant association
between BLLs and hemoglobin levels at 15 months was found. Findings from
this study could be limited in terms of not adjusting for other risk
factors for anemia, including nutritional deficiencies.
Elevated BLLs are clearly a public health concern
among preschool children living in urban slums of Vellore. Poorer
conditions of the living environment seem to be associated with higher
lead levels. More research focusing on the built environment and
behavioral characteristics of children and parents is needed to
understand the exposure pathways in greater detail, and to investigate
causality.
Funding: The Etiology, Risk Factors and
Interactions of Enteric Infections and Malnutrition and the Consequences
for Child Health and Development Project (MAL-ED) is carried out as a
collaborative project supported by the Bill and Melinda Gates
Foundation, the Foundation for the NIH and the National Institutes of
Health/Fogarty International Center. The authors thank the staff and
participants of the MAL-ED Network Project for their important
contributions; Competing Interest: None stated.
What Is Already Known?
•
The burden of lead poisoning is
highest in the developing countries with children being the most
vulnerable group.
What This Study Adds?
•
Nearly half of the pre-school children living in urban slums
of Vellore have elevated blood lead levels and their living
environment plays a role in the exposure pathway.
|
References
1. American Academy of Pediatrics Committee on
Environmental Health. Pediatric environmental health. 2ed. Illinois:
American Academy of Pediatrics; 2003.
2. Mahaffey KR. Nutrition and lead: strategies for
public health. Environ Health Perspect. 1995;103:191-6.
3. World Health Organization. Childhood Lead
Poisoning. Geneva: WHO; 2010.
4. Schwartz J. Low-level lead exposure and children’s
IQ: a meta-analysis and search for a threshold. Environ Res.
1994;65:42-55.
5. Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry.
Toxicological Profile for lead. Atlanta: US Department of Health and
Human Services; 1999.
6. Schwaetz J, Landrigan PJ, Baker EL. Lead induced
anemia: dose response relation and evidence for a threshold. Am J Public
Health. 1990;80:165-8.
7. Turgut S, Polat A, Inan M, Turgut G, Emmungil G,
Bican M, et al. Interaction between anemia and blood levels of
iron, zinc, copper, cadmium and lead in children. Indian J Pediatr.
2007;74:827-30.
8. Zolaly MA, Hanafi MI, Shawky N, El Harbi K,
Mohamadin AM. Association between blood lead levels and environmental
exposure among Saudi school children in certain districts of Al-Madinah.
Int J Gen Med. 2012;5:355-64.
9. Bayley N. Bayley Scales of Infant and Toddler
Development-Third Edition. San Antonio, TX: Harcourt Assessment; 2005.
10. Robertson GJ. Bayley Scales of Infant and Toddler
Development. The Corsini Encyclopedia of Psychology. John Wiley & Sons,
Inc.; 2010.
11. World Health Organization. Haemoglobin
Concentrations for the Diagnosis of Anaemia and Assessment of Severity.
Geneva: Vitamin and Mineral Nutrition Information System, WHO; 2013.
12. World Health Organization. Iron Deficiency Anemia,
Assessment, Prevention and Control: a Guide for Programme Managers.
Geneva: WHO; 2001.
13. Kalra V, Chitralekha KT, Dua T, Pandey RM, Gupta
Y. Blood Lead Levels and risk factors for lead toxicity in children from
schools and an urban slum in Delhi. J Trop Pediatr. 2003;49:121-3.
14. Kalra V, Sahu J, Bedi P, Pandey RM. Blood lead
levels among school children after phasing-out of leaded petrol in
Delhi, India. Indian J Pediatr. 2013;80:636-40.
15. Palaniappan K, Roy A, Balakrishnan K,
Gopalakrishnan L, Mukherjee B, Hu H, et al. Lead exposure and
visual-motor abilities in children from Chennai, India. Neurotoxicology.
2011;32:465-70.
16. Albalak R, Noonan G, Buchanan S, Flanders WD,
Crawford CG, Kim D, et al. Blood lead levels and risk factors for
lead poisoning among children in Jakarta, Indonesia. Sci.Total Environ.
2003;301:75-85.
17. Jain NB, Hu H. Childhood correlates of blood lead
levels in Mumbai and Delhi. Environ Health Perspect. 2006;114:466-70.
18. Needleman HL, Schell A, Bellinger D, Leviton A,
Allred EN. The long-term effects of exposure to low doses of lead in
childhood. An 11-year follow-up report. N Engl J Med. 1990;322:83-8.
19. Needleman HL, Riess JA, Tobin MJ, Biesecker GE,
Greenhouse JB. Bone lead levels and delinquent behavior. JAMA.
1996;275:363-9.
20. Sciarillo WG, Alexander G, Farrell KP. Lead
exposure and child behavior. Am J Public Health. 1992;82:1356-60.
21. Pocock SJ, Smith M, Baghurst P. Environmental lead
and children’s intelligence: a systematic review of the epidemiological
evidence. BMJ. 1994;309:1189-97.
|
|
 |
|