SHORT syndrome (OMIM-269880) is an
acronym consisting of following clinical features: S- short
stature; H- hyperextensibility of joints/ hernia (inguinal);
O-ocular depression; R-rieger anomaly; and T-teething delay.
The most consistent finding, lipodystrophy of face and upper
trunk, was first reported in 1975 [1]. The phenotype has
been expanding since then. There have been a total of 26 case
reports in English literature till date. Autosomal dominant
inheritance has been proposed [2]. Locus of the gene has not
yet been delineated. A recent study had shown that this may
be a contiguous gene deletion syndrome requiring deletion of
1 or more other genes in addition to BMP4 [3].We report an
adolescent with features of lipodystrophy, short stature,
ocular depression, megalocornea, iris hypoplasia with
previously two unreported features of deviated nasal septum
(DNS) and bilateral cryptorchid testis.
Case Report
A 14-year-old boy, product of
consanguineous marriage was referred for work-up of short
stature and associated dysmorphology. He was born as full
term normal vaginal delivery at home, and was small at
birth. At 3 years of age, he was evaluated for bilateral
undescended testis. He underwent exploratory laprotomy with
right orchidopexy and left incomplete orchidopexy with plan
to follow up for second stage left complete orchidopexy
later. At 11 years, left testis was found to atrectic and,
left testicular implant was placed in scrotum. Surgeons
noticed obvious short stature and dysmorphology and referred
the case. Child was proportionately short with a height of
124 cm (<3rd
centile as per WHO growth charts) and US/LS ratio of 0.9.
Bone age and height age were 10-12 years (by Guerlich and
Pyle method) and 7.5 years, respectively. Evaluation
revealed thin built with progeroid facies with loss of
subcutaneous fat mainly in face, trunk and shoulders,
maxillary hypoplasia and dimpled chin (Fig.1).
His development had been normal but punctuated by delay in
acquisition of speech. Ophthalmic evaluation revealed
pseudoenopthalmos, megalocornea, iris hypoplasia,
sphincteric atrophy, venous tortousity with disc pallor (Fig
2). There was no glaucoma or cataract. There was
marked deviation of nasal septum to left side with secondary
hypertrophy of turbinates. Secondary delay in eruption of
permanent teeth was present. Rest of the systemic
examination was not contributory.
|
Fig. 1
Shows loss of subcutaneous fat in face, megalocornea
and deviated nasal septum.
|
|
|
Fig. 2 (a) Fundus showing
disc pallor and venous tortousity.
|
(b) Eyes showing sphincteric
atrophy and iris hypoplasia.
|
Growth hormone stimulation tests, tests
for thyroid function, hormones of pituitary axis and calcium
homeostasis were in normal range. Sonographic examination of
renal system revealed no pathology. Echocardiography, brain
stem auditory evoked response and neuroimaging of brain were
normal. The mother was a nondiabetic with normal insulin and
HbA1C levels. The levels of glucose, insulin and HbA1C were
normal in the proband but were not done in the father.
Comparative array genomic hybridization was done on genomic
DNA using Illumina Human CytoSNP. This test did not reveal
any deletion or duplication of known pathogenic loci. There
was no mutation in the PITX2 gene either.
Discussion
This case has all described features of
acronym SHORT except hyperextensibility/hernia, which is not
a consistent feature of this syndrome [2]. Joint
hyperextensibility was found in only 35% of cases. Few cases
of inguinal hernia have been reported [4,5]. The frequency
of reported features mentioned in acronym SHORT has been
reported as-Short stature (70%), Hyperextensibility (35%),
Ocular depression (100%), Rieger anomaly (77%), and Teething
delay (94%), [2]. Frequencies of other common features but
not part of acronym SHORT in decreasing order of their
occurrence are-lack of subcutaneous fat/very thin (100%),
abnormal ears (95%), hypoplastic alae nasi (94%), normal
intellect (90%), delayed bone age (82%), triangular face
(80%), megalocornea (64%), micrognathia (65%). Clinical
phenotype frequency suggest, that lipodystrophy and ocular
depression are two unique and cardinal features present in
all patients. Our patient also expressed this consistent
phenotype besides two new previously unreported features
viz., deviated nasal septum and bilateral cryptorchid
testis.
Lipodystrophy is manifested mostly by
lack of subcutaneous fat in face, chest and upper
extremities, relatively sparing the legs. Lipodystrophy is
not progressive, but seems to become apparent with age.
Taken together, the predominant feature in SHORT syndrome is
the lipodystrophy rather than short stature. Unfortunately,
this cardinal feature is not mentioned in the mnemonic
SHORT.
Autosomal dominant inheritance has been
suggested but genetic basis of SHORT syndrome is currently
poorly understood. Both autosomal dominant inheritance
described by Gorlin, et al. [1] and autosomal
recessive described by Sensenbrenner, et al. [4] have
been postulated. Our case could be autosomal recessive as
was born to consanguineous parents or could be sporadic [2].
A familial translocation t(1;4) (q31.2;q25) was identified,
presumably disrupting the PITX2 locus, in a child with SHORT
syndrome and his mother with Axenfeld-Rieger syndrome and
polycystic ovary syndrome but the family demonstrated
occurrence of both Reiger syndrome and insulin
resistance[6].Our case did not demonstrate the insulin
resistance and array was not contributory in our case.
BMP4 loss of function mutations have been
described in patients with SHORT syndrome, Axenfeld-Rieger
malformation, growth delay, macrocephaly, and diaphragmatic
hernia. The authors postulated the critical role of this in
ocular development. Studies in animal models have shown that
Bmp4 and Pitx2 act in a common pathway in
craniofacial/dental and left-right asymmetry development
[3]. However, the definite locus of SHORT syndrome gene
still remains illusive.
Contributors: AS was involved
in clinical case management and was the main author. RA did
the opthalmoscopic evaluation and PS did the genetic
studies.SK critically reviewed the manuscript, made the
diagnosis and will act as guarantor for the manuscript
Funding: None; Competing interests:
None stated.
References
1. Sensenbrenner JA, Hussels IE, Levin
LS. A low birthweight syndrome,? Rieger syndrome. Birth
Defects Orig Art Ser. 1975; 11:423-6.
2. Koenig R, Brendel L, Fuchs S. SHORT
syndrome. Clin. Dysmorphol. 2003;12:45-9.
3. Reis LM, Tyler RC, Schilter
KF, Abdul-Rahman O, Innis JW, Kozel BA, et al . BMP4
loss-of-function mutations in developmental eye disorders
including SHORT syndrome. Hum Genet. 2011;130:495-504.
4. Gorlin RJ. A selected miscellany.
Birth Defects Orig Art Ser. 1975;11:46-8.
5. Aarskog D, Ose L, Pande H, Eide N.
Autosomal dominant partial lipodystrophy associated with
Rieger anomaly, short stature, and insulinopenic diabetes.
Am J Med Genet.1983;15:29-38.
6. Karadeniz NN, Kocak-Midillioglu I, Erdogan D, Bökesoy
I.Is SHORT syndrome another phenotypic variation of PITX2?
Am J Med Genet. 2004;130A:406-9.