Social and emotional learning (SEL) is the process through which
children and adults understand and manage emotions, set and achieve
positive goals, feel and show empathy for others, establish and maintain
positive relationships, and make responsible decisions [1]. Currently,
in India, SEL is not being given importance due to changing lifestyle,
urbanization, both parents working, single child, and non-availability
of secure play areas etc. Children are sent to preschool early, with a
focus on academics rather than on personal development. This makes them
socially and emotionally detached [2]. We share our experience of a
short duration SEL program at kindergarten level.
Children aged 5-6 years, studying in upper
kindergarten were enrolled in the program, and data of those with
attendance less than 80% in the SEL program was excluded. An
introductory class was taken for the parents about SEL. School
administrators, teachers and parents were actively involved throughout
the sessions. Eleven hours of the program was conducted over 6 weeks (1
hour session, 2 per week, conducted by a trained psychologists).
Children were given work sheets and fun activities as home project to
ensure parental partici-pation. Questionnaires based on the social skill
improvement system were administered to the parents before and after the
sessions to see the effect of the program. School was given inputs to
integrate SEL into the curriculum. Teachers’ comments were also taken
into consideration to identify any problem behaviors. The SSIS (Social
skill improvement system) parent form (social skills subdomain, 3-5
years) was used to provide a picture of child’s behavior in multiple
settings. However, due to the large number of students to teacher ratio
(40:1), the teacher form was not included. The Kimochis Educator’s Tool
Kit was used. It is a universal, school-based, social emotional learning
curriculum designed to give children the knowledge, skills and attitudes
they need to recognize and manage their emotions.
113 children (58 boys; mean age, 5.3 years) were
included in the study, and classified to two groups based on the
behavior levels obtained from the pre-SEL questionnaire. Group 1 (n=23)
had below average and well below average level on social skills sub
scale, and children in group 2 (n=90) had an average, above
average and well above average level of social skills. The mean score
for each of the social skill sub-domain raw scores (communication,
cooperation, assertion, responsi-bility, empathy, engagement and
self-control) and total score was calculated for groups. Analysis of
variance (ANOVA) was used to compare scores between the groups. Analysis
was done using Microsoft Excel. A 5% level of significance was
considered significant.
In Group 1, 15 (65.2%) children showed an improvement
in the total social skills raw score following the intervention. There
was a significant improvement in mean (SD) total social skills score
after the intervention [64.7 (8.16) vs. 72.1 (10.74); P<0.01],
indicating short term Kimochi training is effective for children. In
Group B, 40 showed an improvement in the total social skill score and 47
(44.4%) children showed reduction in scores. No statistically
significant difference was noted in the pre-and post-intervention mean
(SD) total skill score in this group [91.3 (14.26) vs 90.8 (16.21); P=0.82].
However, follow-up is needed to see the impact of the
skills learned, as children need time to practice and integrate the
learned skills (sleeper effect) [3]. The CASEL meta-analysis [4] noted
that though impact is maximum immediately, it still persists, though the
impact of the program tends to fade.
At the closing session of our program, parents were
advised how to promote SEL at home. Children with problem behaviors were
guided appropriately. Preschool teachers’ workshop was conducted to
promote professional development and early identification of
developmental problems. We feel that our experience shall promote more
studies to establish healthy SEL at schools, especially in the Indian
scenario, where there is a paucity of the same.
Acknowledgement: Dr Nandini Mundkur,
Developmental Paediatrician, Center for Child Development and
Disabilities, Bengaluru, Karnataka, India.
REFERENCES
1. The Collaborative for Academic, Social, and
Emotional Learning (CASEL). Accessed March 20, 2021. Available from:
https://casel.org/
2. Rajawat D, Patel RC. Identifying the tenets for
socio-emotional learning (SEL) and development of pre-schoolers. ISOR -
JRME. 2015;5:25-38.
3. Blewitt C, Fuller-Tyszkiewicz M, Nolan A, et al.
Social and emotional learning associated with universal curriculum-based
interventions in early childhood education and care centre: A systematic
review and meta-analysis. JAMA Network Open. 2018;1: e185727.
4. Mahoney J, Durlak J, Weissberg RP. An update on social and
emotional learning outcome research, 2018. Accessed March 20, 2021.
Available from:
https://kappanonline.org/social-emotional-learning-outcome-research-mahoney-durlak-weissberg/