1.gif (1892 bytes)

Brief Report

Indian Pediatrics 1999; 36:174-177 

Clinical and Computerised Tomography Evaluation of Term Neonates with Perinatal Asphyxia


Chitra Ayyapan
P. Amutha Rajeswari
N. Edwin

From the Government Rajaji Hospital, Madurai 625020, India.

Reprint requests: Dr. Chitra Ayyappan, 3/238, Lake Avenue-//, Narayanapuram,
Madurai -
625 014, India.

India. Manuscript received: February 2,1998; Initial review completed: March 24, 1998;
Revision accepted: September 22, 1998.

 

Asphyxia triggers a cascade of cellular biochemical events that lead to tissue hypoxia and ischemia(1). Much of our current under- standing concerning the pathophysiology of perinatal brain disorders has evolved from animal studies(2). The relationship of severity of hypoxic injury to the brain and neurological outcome needs to be assessed carefully(3-5). Apgar score undoubtedly serves to predict neurologic outcome. However, fallacies in its ability to predict prognosis compelled the use of other diagnostic strategies like EEG, transfontanellar sonography and cranial CT in conjunction with neurological examination(6- 9). A ,CT evaluation of term asphyxiated neonates born in Government Rajaji Hospital, Madurai was undertaken to find out the pat- tern of intracranial changes and to correlate them with the type of obstetric intervention, Apgar score and clinical staging of Sarnat.

Subjects and Methods

Twenty three term neonates admitted with evidence of Hypoxia Ischemic Encephalopathy (HIE) formed, the subjects for the
present study. Only those neonates who satisfied at least two of the following criteria were included in the study: (a) Evidence of perinatal asphyxia (peripartum asphyxia/birth asphyxia) defined as fetal bradycardia, meconium staining of the fetus, fetal heart irregularities (as assessed by intermittent auscultation); (b) Apgar scroe less than 7 at one minute; (c) Need for resuscitation; (d) Abnormal neurological signs such as seizures, altered muscle tone and abnormal neurological reflexes; and (e) Free from any associated neurological, cardiac, respiratory or other malformations, metabolic disorders, bleeding diathesis and shock. The cases were grouped under standard Apgar score and also classified into Sarnat stages I, II and III. Details, of antenatal history, drug therapy, previous registration, regular follow up; place and mode of delivery, and drugs used during delivery were recorded in the proforma. All the 23 term newborns were subjected to Computerised. Tomography (CT) within 48 hours after delivery using HITACHI model CT W 4 lOA. Ten transverse sections were taken. No contrast scan was made. All the cranial CT scans were analyzed and reviewed in an unbiased manner by the Radiologist without the clinical details and later the authors discussed them with the case details and the results were recorded and interpreted. Areas of hyperdensity were considered to represent hemorrhage and the density was measured by computerised inbuilt technique., Hemorrhages were classified according to its location. In addition areas of hypodensity and calcification were looked into. Ventricular size was also measured in all patients(10). Clinical data and outcome were subjected to statistical analysis using Chi square test.

Results

There were 16 males and 7 females in the study group. Nine males and 'one female in the study group expired. One of the four babies whose weight was below 2500 grams and 9 of the 19 above 2500 grams expired. The mean 1 minute Apgar was 4.2 among 10 deaths and 4.7 among 13 alive. The mean 5 minute Apgar was 6.7 among the 10 deaths and 7 among the 13 alive. The correlation between 1 minute Apgar and CT findings among the 10 deaths was not significant. However, 5 minute Apgar and CT findings had a significant statistical correlation (p <0.05). Eight out of 15 (53.3%) of babies who had compressed ventricles expired and 2 out of 8 (25%) of babies with normal ventricles died. Six of the 12 neonates (50%) without convulsions and four of II with convulsions died in the present study.

Of 23 neonates, 8 had stage I HIE, 5 had stage II HIE, and 10 had stage III HIE. On CT scan (Table 1) cerebral edema was seen in 21, while intracranial hemorrhage was seen in.12. All 3 babies in Stage III HIE with severe cerebral edema died (1 delivered by Caesarean and 2 were delivered normally). There was no death with cerebral edema in stage I and stage II HIE. Of 2 neonates in stage I with cerebral hemorrhage, I child had retrobulbar hemorrhage (forceps delivery) and the other had subdural hemorrhage (Breech delivery) and both of them survived. Of 3 neonates in stage II with cerebral hemorrhage, 2 babies had' straight sinus bleed and 1 had intra cerebellar bleed, and there was no death. Of 7 babies in stage III, 3 had subgaleal bleed, 3 had intraparenchymal bleeds and 1 neonate had subdural bleed and all these 7 delivered by forceps succumbed.
 

TABLE I

Correlation Between Sarnat Staging and CT Findings

 Samat's No. CT findings     Dead Alive
stage            
  8 Normal 2   - 2
    Cerebral edema 4   - 4
    Hemorrhage and   Retrobulbar Hge-l. - 2
    Cerebral edema 2 SDH-I    
II 5 Normal -      
    Cerebral edema 2   - 2
    Hemorrhage and        
    Cerebral edema 3 SAH And straight sinus bleed-2    
        Intra cerebellar bIeed-1 - 3
III 10 Normal -   -  
    Cerebral edema 3   3  
    Muliple   SGH -3    
    hemorrhages and        
    cerebral edema 7 IPH -3    
        SDH -1 7  


Hge-Hemorrhage; IPH-Intraparenchymal hemorrhage;
SDH-Subdural hemorrhage; SAH-Sub-arachnoid hemorrhage SGH-Subgaleal hemorrhage


Discussion

In our study, patient selection criteria was
similar to earlier studies(II). The pathogenesis of ICH in term neonates is poorly defined. Parenchymal hemorrhage can occur with trauma, disorders of homeostasis, hypertension or A V malformations(12). In the present study major bleeding was suspected and diagnosed by CT within the first 2 days oflife(13). Surgical removal of the blood clot was not contemplated as previous studies showed disappointing results(14).

Fenichel et al. have highlighted the incidence of ICH in term neonates as diagnosed on CT Scan. Over a period of 5 years, 22 term newborns with ICH were detected, of which 19 had SAH, 8 had IVH, and 4 IPH while none had SDH(IO). In our series 3 had IPH, 3 had subgaleal hemorrhage, 2 had subdural hemorrhage, one had iritracerebellar hemorrhage, 2 had SAH and 1 had retrobulbar hemorrhage. In Fenichel' s series, 10 out of 22 had HIE and 16 out of 22 had abnormal deliveries(10). In our study also there were 10 cases with severe HIE and 17
had abnormal deliveries which is comparable to Feniches series(10).

In the present study mortality with IPH was 100%. A worse prognosis with IVH and IPH has been documented by earlier workers(12,15). In another study(16), 6 full term neonates (3 with IVH and 3 with IPH) 6 were all alive. One child had development retardation, 1 had minor difficulties while the other four had good scholastic performances, and they conclude that the prognosis for IVH and IPH is better in full term than in preterm infants. These results are in contrast to other reports where IVH and IPH were assessed to have worse prognosis(15).

The CT findings of intracranial hemorrhmal hemorrhage was similar in 2 breech and II vacuum extracted babies, while 3 breech delivered infants had IVH. According to them all 11 vacuum extracted babies showed complete resolution, while none of the breech had a normal outcome. All 5 of the latter group had hydrocephalus; one case each demonstrated porencephaly and encephalomalacia. In the present study there was only I breech delivered infant, staged in Sarnat I, who had subdural hemorrhage and survived. There was no vacuum extracted baby, though there were 14 babies delivered by forceps of whom 11 had evidence of ICH (2 with SDH, SAH in 2, intracerebellar bleed in 1, SGH in 3 and IPH in 3). In the present study, 70% of neonatal deaths occured, in infants delivered by forceps. Similar studies on forceps delivery and ICH were not available for comparison.

The use of real time ultrasound in ICH limits itself to diagnosis of SAH, IVH and supratentoreal IPH( 18). CT provided greater confidence than ultrasound for diagnosis or exclusion of neonatal ischemia or hemorrhage and also had better inter-observer agreement(13). CT is capable of diagnosing accurately acute hemorrhage in asphyxiated neonates and might be re-comment.

 

 References


1. Johnston MY. Cellular alterations associated with perinatal asphyxia. Clini Invest Med 1993; 16: 122-132.

2.
Raju MTN. Some animal models for the study of perinatal asphyxia. Biol Neonate 1992; 4: 202-214.

3.MacDonald HM, Mulligan JC, Allen AC, Taylor PM. Neonatal asphyxia: Relationship of obstetric and neonatal complications to neonatal mortality in '38, 405 consecutive deliveries. J Pediatr 1980; 96: 893-902.

4.Mullian JC, Painter MJ, '0' Donohue PA, MacDonal HM, Allen AC, Taylor PM. Neonatal asphyxia: II. Neonatal mortality and long-term sequelae. J Pediatr 1980; 96: 903- 907.

5. Deorari AK, Paul YK, Singh M. Birth asphyxia and neuro-developmental outcome. Indian Pediatr 1989; 26: 793-799.

6. Castro-Conde MJR, Domenech Martinez ME. Prognosis of perinatal asphyxia in full term neonates. AD. Esp Pediatr 1993; 38: 323-329.

7. Merchant R, Yaz NP, Goudinho N, Desai MP. Electroencephalography in evaluation of term asphyxiated neonates. Indian Pediatr 1985; 22: 585-595.

8. Goen EW, McCutchen CH, Warner 0, Snyder J, Gluck FE. Continuous monitoring of the EEG following perinatal asphyxia. J Pediatr 1982; 100:628-630.

9. Merchant R, Chablani Y, Parekh N, Goudinho N, Vas NP. CT and EEG in the immediate evaluation of some infants with symptomatic birth asphyxia, Indian J Pediatr 1984; 51: 327- 332.

10. Fenichel GM, Webster DL, Wong WKT. In-tracranial hemorrhage in the term newborn. Arch Neuro11984; 41: 30-34.

11. Merchant RH, Shah A, Abhyankars, Joshi NC. . CT scan evaluation of term neonates with symptomatic .birth asphyxia. Indian Pediatr 1987; 24: 53-58.

12. Merchant RH, Divekar RM. Intracranial hemorrhage in term neonates. Indian Pediatr 1987; 24: 503-507.

13. Blankenberg FG, Norbash AM, Lane B, Stevenson OK, Bracci PM, Enzmann DR. Neonatal intracranial ischemia and. hemorrhage: Diagnosis with US, CT and MR imaging. Radiology 1996; 6: 253-259.

14. Fitzhardinge PM, Flodmark I, Fitz CR, Ashby S. The prognostic value of CT as an adjunct to assessment of term infant with postasphyxial encephalopathy. J Pediatr 1981; 99: 777-778.

15. Bergman I, Bauer RE, Barmada MA, Latchaw RE, Taylor GH, David R. et al. Intracerebral hemorrhage in full term neonatal infant. Pediat- rics 1985; 75: 488-496.

16. Sizun J, Blanchard C, Rubios S, Giroux JD, Alix D. Cerebral intraventricular and/or intraparenchymal hemorrhages in full term newborn infants: Long term outcome. Arch Fr Pediatr 1993; 50: 681-683.

17. Obdita JC, Hebi S. CT and MRI characteristics of intracranial hemorrhage complicating breech and vacuum delivery. Pediatr Radio1 1996; 26: 782-785.

18. Soni JP, Gupta BD, Soni M, Gupta M, Dhabi DR, Neonate KR. Ultrasonic diagnosis of intracranial hemorrhage in high risk neonates. Indian Pediatr 1995; 32: 453-460.

19. Khane MD, Merchant RH. Diagnostic and prognostic value of CT brain scan in term neonates with moderate and severe birth asphyxia. Indian Pediatr 1990; 27: 267-271.
 

Home

Past Issue

About IP

About IAP

Feedback

Links

 Author Info.

  Subscription