An
original research paper on ‘nephrotic syndrome in children’ was
published in the December 1966 issue of Indian Pediatrics, from
the department of Pediatrics MGM Medical College, Indore. We decided to
review this article to trace the evolution in the diagnosis and
management stra-tegies for this condition since that era.
The Past
The study by Bhandari, et al. [1], was
amongst the early published original articles on nephrotic syndrome from
India. This study, conducted on 75 children with nephrotic syndrome,
compares the effect of treatment with long- and short-term regimes of
oral steroid therapy.
Nephrotic syndrome was defined by the authors as the
presence of edema, hypoproteinemia, hyperlipidemia and proteinuria, and
an absence of persistent hypertension, azotemia and gross hematuria.
More than half (52%) of included children were aged between 2 and 5
years at first presentation, with male preponderance (62%). Generalized
edema was the commonest (73%) presenting complaint. While azotemia and
hypertension were found in less than 30% of the patients, nearly half
had microscopic hematuria. Kidney biopsy performed in four patients
revealed subacute nephritis in two and hypercellular glomeruli with
degenerative changes in tubular epithelium in the other two patients.
All the patients received a general treatment
comprising of antibiotics, diuretics, and a high protein and salt-free
diet. To study the effect of different treatment regimens, the patients
were divided into three groups: Group I (20 patients) received general
treatment alone, Group II (35 patients) received short-term steroids
(10-21) days in addition to general treatment, and Group III (20
patients) received long intermittent steroid therapy ranging from 6
weeks to 30 months. Resolution of edema and albuminuria, and onset of
diuresis were considered as indicators of improvement. The most
favourable response to treatment was observed in patients in group III;
65% subjects in this group had complete resolution of edema as opposed
to 30% in group I and 51% in group II. Children in group III also showed
the least recurrence of edema. The authors concluded that the patients
who received steroids for longer periods, especially those who were
treated for more than one year, showed better clinical response and had
longer periods of remission.
Historical background and past knowledge: The
earliest mention of nephrotic syndrome dates back to Hippocrates who
made an important observation about the disease that ‘when bubbles
settle on the surface of the urine, it indicates disease of the kidneys,
and that the complaint will be protracted’ [2]. In 1827, Richard
Bright described the triad of generalized edema, proteinuria, and kidney
disease [3], and in 1905, Müller coined the term ‘nephrosis’ to describe
all non-inflammatory diseases of the kidney [4].
The understanding of this disease at the time of
publication of the study by Bhandari, et.al [1] is reflected in
the review by Derow in New England Journal of Medicine in the year 1958
[5]. The patients with nephrotic syndrome were classified as: (i)
those with known etiologic associations (e.g. syphilis, malaria,
SLE, poisoning with heavy metal, poison-oak, bee-sting and trimethadione
or paramethadione), and (ii) those where etiology was unknown –
referred to as idiopathic nephrotic syndrome or ‘lipoid nephrosis.’ The
pathogenesis in the latter was believed to be complement-mediated
antigen-antibody reaction that produced tissue damage [6].
Renal biopsy – introduced in the routine clinical
nephrology practice in late 1950s – transformed the understanding of
pathogenesis of this disorder. With the advent of electron microscopy,
characteristic histopathological findings in idiopathic disease were
described [7]. During that time, ACTH and the adrenocortical steroids
were the agents of choice for specific treatment for nephrotic syndrome.
Sometime later, in 1965, International Study for Kidney Disease in
Children (ISKDC), a multinational group, defined heavy proteinuria, dose
regimen of prednisolone and response to prednisolone therapy. The
criteria defining relapses and steroid-dependence and steroid-resistance
were also laid down [8].
The Present
Over the last three or four decades, ISKDC, through
multi-centre prospective trials, established treatment-oriented
classifications and standardised management guidelines for nephrotic
syndrome. In the current era, advanced genetic and molecular studies
promise an opportunity to provide individualised care to children with
nephrotic syndrome.
The Indian Pediatric Nephrology Group formulated
guidelines for treatment of steroid sensitive nephrotic syndrome in 2001
which were subsequently revised in 2008 [9]. The guidelines provide
recommendations on investigations and treatment of the initial episode
of nephrotic syndrome, indications of alternative medications (mycophenolate
mofetil, cyclosporin and tacrolimus) in patients with frequent relapses
and steroid dependence and management of complications. The same group
described management guidelines of steroid-resistant nephrotic syndrome
in early 2009 [10]. More recently, evidence-based clinical practice
guidelines were published by the Kidney Disease: Improving Global
Outcomes (KDIGO) working group for management of nephrotic syndrome and
glomerulonephritis [11].
Various randomized trials from India have, since
then, examined the effect of long (5-6 months) versus short (2-3
months) duration prednisolone therapy in treatment of first episode of
nephrotic syndrome, on frequency of subsequent relapses [12,13]. A
recent Cochrane review found that there was no significant difference in
the risk for relapse between the two regimens, indicating that there is
no benefit of increasing the duration of prednisone in the first episode
beyond two or three months [14].
For treatment of steroid-resistant nephrotic
syndrome, calcineurin inhibitors are found to be better in inducing
remission as compared to cyclophosphamide [15]. Rituximab, a monoclonal
antibody against CD20 antigen on B-lymphocyte, is now an established
steroid sparing agent used in frequently-relapsing and steroid-dependent
nephrotic syndrome. The introduction of next-generation sequencing
techniques has helped in exploring the genetic mutations causing
nephrotic syndrome, especially the congenital, familial and
steroid-resistant varieties. It has led to a better understanding of the
pathophysiologic mechanisms altering glomerular filtration barrier, and
holds promise for future research.
References
1. Bhandari NR, Bhoraskar SN. Nephrotic syndrome in
children. Indian Pediatr. 1966;3:422-7.
2. Chadwick J. The Medical Works of Hippocrates: A
New Translation from the Original Greek (Vol. 174). Oxford: Blackwell
(1950) (Section 7, No34).
3. Bright R. Reports of Medical Cases. London: Orme
(1827)
4. Müller F. Morbus Brightii. Verh Dtsch Ges Path.
1905;9: 64-99.
5. Derow HA. The nephrotic syndrome. N Engl J Med.
1958;258;77-82.
6. Lange K, Strang R, Slobody LB, Wenk EJ. Treatment
of nephrotic syndrome with steroids in children and adults. Arch Int
Med. 1957;99:760-70.
7. Allen AC. The Kidney: Medical and Surgical
diseases. New York: Grune and Stratton. 1951; p. 583.
8. International Study of Kidney Disease in Children.
Nephrotic syndrome in children: Prediction of histopathology from
clinical and laboratory characteristics at the time of diagnosis. Kidney
Int. 1978;13:159-65.
9. Bagga A, Ali U, Banerjee S, Kanitkar M, Phadke KD,
Senguttuvan P, et. al. Management of steroid sensitive nephritic
syndrome: revised guidelines. Indian Pediatr. 2008;45:203-14.
10. Gulati A, Bagga A, Gulati S, Mehta KP,
Vijayakumar M. Management of steroid resistant nephrotic syndrome.
Indian Pediatr. 2009;46:35-47.
11. Kidney Disease: Improving Global Outcomes (KDIGO)
Glomerulonephritis Work Group. KDIGO Clinical Practice Guideline for
Glomerulonephritis. Kidney Int Suppl. 2012;2:139-274.
12. Mishra OP, Thakur N, Mishra RN, Prasad R.
Prolonged versus standard prednisolone therapy for initial episode of
idiopathic nephrotic syndrome. J Nephrol. 2012; 25:3 94-400.
13. Sinha A, Saha A, Kumar M, Sharma S, Afzal K,
Mehta A, et. al. Extending initial prednisolone treatment in a
randomized control trial from 3 to 6 months did not significantly
influence the course of illness in children with steroid-sensitive
nephrotic syndrome. Kidney Int. 2014;87:217-24.
14. Hahn D, Hodson EM, Willis NS, Craig JC.
Corticosteroid therapy for nephrotic syndrome in children. Cochrane
Database Syst Rev. 2015;3:CD001533.
15. Hodson EM, Wong SC, Willis NS, Craig JC.
Interventions for idiopathic steroid-resistant nephrotic syndrome in
child-ren. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2016;10:CD003594.